Bad Deal - Does this sound fair?

Anything that is gaming related that doesn't fit well anywhere else
Post Reply
User avatar
winds
128-bit
Posts: 653
Joined: Sat May 03, 2008 8:26 pm
Location: Canada

Bad Deal - Does this sound fair?

Post by winds »

Hey guys,
So after my recent horrible gamestop experience I wrote about a few weeks ago, now I seem to be having another one with an online auction. I need help understanding this because maybe i'm wrong and just not seeing it clearly...
I buy a lot of stuff from online japan auctions, since I live in Canada I have to use deputy services such as rinkya or celga to do my bidding. About 2 months ago I won an auction, and since I do a lot of bidding and it's expensive to get it shipped to me, I usually wait until I accumulate quite a bit of stuff before finally shipping it to my house from Japan. This item was won 2 months ago so... quite a bit of time I suppose.
Anyway, I received the package full of the stuff I won a few days ago, everything was perfect like always, however this one aucion I won was supposed to include the following:
Image

I am a huuuuge collector of all things suikoden, so this auction included a hand mirror only given out at TGS, along with those 2 alternate covers/flyers for suikoden 5. I spent a little more than I would have specifically on this auction because it included both, with deputy service commissions, I would have had to pay a lot more had I bid on these 2 items seperately. Now when I received this package, it ONLY came with the hand mirror, the 2 covers were not to be found.
The original auction stated this as the description: ハンドミラー、未開封新品です。非売品。おまけでチラシおつけ致します。
If anyone can read Japanese and let me know what that says, please do haha. However in the meantime I use google translator which says: "Hand mirror, new unopened. Sale. Flyers will be worn on bonus."
Now when I emailed the deputy service about it, they said they will try to ask the seller if he still has them, but if they dont there is absolutely nothing they can do, since these items were labelled as a "gift". What?
That is where I become infinitely confused. By their logic I can create an auction for my car, with a buy it now price of $4000. Then in the description I can put "Please send me 4000 dollars, and as a gift i'll send you my car" Then when I don't send my car, I can just tell the buyer "sorry but that was only a gift..."
Does this make sense? The seller forgets to send them, my deputy service fails to check, and the buyer pays the price? Sounds backwards to me and really unfair. Am I right or is there something i'm not seeing?
Nintendoes what Nintendon't!

Tangerine Orange Key: 42915767S1
User avatar
Inazuma
Next-Gen
Posts: 2940
Joined: Thu Jul 23, 2009 11:35 pm
Location: USA

Re: Bad Deal - Does this sound fair?

Post by Inazuma »

winds wrote: The original auction stated this as the description: ハンドミラー、未開封新品です。非売品。おまけでチラシおつけ致します。
If anyone can read Japanese and let me know what that says, please do haha. However in the meantime I use google translator which says: "Hand mirror, new unopened. Sale. Flyers will be worn on bonus."
I'd translate the Japanese as:
Hand mirror, unopened and brand new. Not for sale. As a bonus, I will include some leaflets.
*edit*
I left out the middle sentence by mistake.
User avatar
winds
128-bit
Posts: 653
Joined: Sat May 03, 2008 8:26 pm
Location: Canada

Re: Bad Deal - Does this sound fair?

Post by winds »

Thanks Inazuma!
I'm going to assume the Not for Sale part is directly talking about the fact that the hand mirror wasn't originally for sale. I know it was part of a tokyo game show years ago, but on the barcode it says NOT FOR SALE on it.
And him saying he will include the pamphlets seems pretty self explanatory to me. With him saying that, they are in fact part of the auction. Whether it was meant as a bonus or not, they were what I was bidding on.
Nintendoes what Nintendon't!

Tangerine Orange Key: 42915767S1
User avatar
Inazuma
Next-Gen
Posts: 2940
Joined: Thu Jul 23, 2009 11:35 pm
Location: USA

Re: Bad Deal - Does this sound fair?

Post by Inazuma »

winds wrote:Thanks Inazuma!
I'm going to assume the Not for Sale part is directly talking about the fact that the hand mirror wasn't originally for sale. I know it was part of a tokyo game show years ago, but on the barcode it says NOT FOR SALE on it.
And him saying he will include the pamphlets seems pretty self explanatory to me. With him saying that, they are in fact part of the auction. Whether it was meant as a bonus or not, they were what I was bidding on.
Correct.

You are right to complain and ask for the leaflets he was supposed to give you, but since it has been 2 months, I don't know if you can file a proper complaint about it. Either way, it couldn't hurt to ask.
Post Reply