I realize that Star Trek isn't for everyone. That's totally cool. But I saw this promo, and all I could think of was, "This isn't Star Trek."
If the filmmakers think Star Trek needs to be taken in another direction, that's fine... but that's what spinoffs are for. If the perception was that Enterprise and Nemesis indicated that Star Trek had headed into undesirable territory, they should have started by fixing those problems or by just beginning afresh with a radically different new spinoff.
Reinventing the well-established and long-dormant original series to forgive the sins of its progeny or to blaze a trail for the next next generation of Star Trek seems about as illogical as giving a World War II veteran the Six Million Dollar Man treatment so that he can serve in Iraq in place of any of his capable (flawed or not) children and grandchildren.
Yet, there's nothing I can do about it, so I'm gonna sit here like a loyal fan and eat whatever they shovel at me and hope that it tastes better than it looks.
New Star Trek trailer!
- Flashman85
- 16-bit
- Posts: 86
- Joined: Fri Aug 15, 2008 1:59 pm
- Location: USA
- Contact:
- Doctor Fugue
- 128-bit
- Posts: 936
- Joined: Wed Jan 23, 2008 5:50 pm
- Location: Canada
- Contact:
Re: New Star Trek trailer!
HOLY SHIT
"Your vessel, your beginning. All that you knew...is gone." - The Guardian of Forever
Re: New Star Trek trailer!
I'd agree with this but Voyager finished forever when they got home and I am more than doubtful you'd get half the DS9 cast back for a film or something.Scooter wrote:Personally, I'd rather see a few well done movies based on the DS9 or Voyager stories and casts. I think some of the best Star Trek ever was done in those series.
Was anybody else not convinced by Janeway's 40 a day smoker's voice?
Atari ST, Atari 2600, Commodore 64, Master System, NES, Mega Drive, 32X, SNES, Amiga CD32, Atari Jaguar, Saturn, Playstation, N64, Dreamcast, Playstation 2, Gamecube, Xbox360, Wii
Gamegear, Lynx, Gameboy (100s of the bloody things), Game & Watches (coming out of my ears)
Gamegear, Lynx, Gameboy (100s of the bloody things), Game & Watches (coming out of my ears)
Re: New Star Trek trailer!
Voyager just didn't click with me. It was watchable but the crew lacked chemistry. Probably because of offstage interpersonal problems.
Thy ban hammer shalt strike 

Re: New Star Trek trailer!
Well, the other crews (storyline-wise) were disbanded and reconstituted too so per the Voyager storyline that wouldn't be too hard. Concerning the DS9 crew, perhaps. But money talks. It wasn't easy to reconstitute the original cast for the TOS movies but it still got done.Chrono wrote:I'd agree with this but Voyager finished forever when they got home and I am more than doubtful you'd get half the DS9 cast back for a film or something.Scooter wrote:Personally, I'd rather see a few well done movies based on the DS9 or Voyager stories and casts. I think some of the best Star Trek ever was done in those series.
Was anybody else not convinced by Janeway's 40 a day smoker's voice?
Kate Mulgrew like starship captains before her, was trained in stage acting (probably a lot of Shakespere too like Shatner and Stewart) and that stage acting method tends to come through a lot.
You must not have seen much of the last two seasons. It actually got pretty good then. The overall ending was rather anti-climactic though. A little epilogue would have been a really good idea.Pulsar_t wrote:Voyager just didn't click with me. It was watchable but the crew lacked chemistry. Probably because of offstage interpersonal problems.
Ow! My small intestine!
Re: New Star Trek trailer!
I was never much a fan of the series, any of them, really, except for the later few seasons of TNG. I do, however, love the original cast movies. Hah! What DOES God need with a starship?
Re: New Star Trek trailer!
http://www.metacritic.com/film/titles/startrek2009
w00t didn't expect so many positive reviews! Definitely worth watching!
w00t didn't expect so many positive reviews! Definitely worth watching!
Thy ban hammer shalt strike 

- johnnydoyle123
- 24-bit
- Posts: 101
- Joined: Sat May 02, 2009 9:30 am
Re: New Star Trek trailer!
i really loved star trek deep space 9 ... but the rest dident really fit with me probably why im very much into this movie ..
going to see it tommorow
going to see it tommorow
http://www.youtube.com/ajgamesinsider
currently collecting : pc engine / nec consoles and games
specializing in rare games ,,,,, and weird stuff no ones hear off
currently collecting : pc engine / nec consoles and games
specializing in rare games ,,,,, and weird stuff no ones hear off
Re: New Star Trek trailer!
Im going to go see this this weekend. I expect it to suck hard. Doesnt reall look like Trek to me...more like just some big summer action flick. We'll see.





