I'm a big fan of 1up.com, mostly for their incredibly talented/honest writing staff and amazingly entertaining podcasts. They have a new cover story up. Page 2 consists of their favorite retro features of 2009. I highly recommend it.
Been a fan since they launched. I was an EGM reader so I naturally checked it out. While I don't visit the site as much as I used to, I listen to many of the podcasts religiously.