You've got a PS1, Saturn & Dreamcast (hypothetical question)

[Gunstar Green]

For me it would be the Dreamcast easily. I don't have a Saturn or have the drive to get one and I barely ever touch my PS1. I'm also not a fan of the awkward 3D pioneer generation.

[CRTGAMER]

DO NOT SELL ANYTHING
Too many times I read where members regret selling some or all of their systems. The irony is the consoles and games sold costs much more to replace when starting over again. Just put the non played consoles to the side, you might play them again years later.

Then there is this, applies to disc based memory cards too.

I just realized the copy of Donkey Kong 64 that I just sent to someone is the one I put so much hard work into getting 101% (or whatever) on. Now I'm left with a copy that just has 3 empty save files.

[AppleQueso]

DO NOT SELL ANYTHING
Too many times I read where members regret selling some or all of their systems. The irony is the consoles and games sold costs much more to replace when starting over again. Just put the non played consoles to the side, you might play them again years later.

Oh man tell me about it.

Still haven't gotten back all the crap I've sold off.

[KDub]

If I can only keep one out of those three I'd keep the Dreamcast, no contest.

The Saturn would be the only one that would give me trouble in parting with. I have little to no desire for the PS1 (or PS2). Every time I go to get some retro games and I look over the PS1 section I usually don't buy anything; either making me me say "meh" or I'd rather have it on another system.

[AppleQueso]

To better answer the thread question though:

I'd give up the Dreamcast first. Many of its best games have ports on other platforms nowadays. There's not really a lot I'd miss for it truthfully.

Playstation vs Saturn would be kinda a tough call for me. Assuming I can wuss out and just use a Ps2 for Ps1 games I'd keep the Saturn. If not... I'll probably still keep the Saturn anyway. Saturn has a lot of genuinely unique experiences.

[fastbilly1]

If only one - Saturn.
If two - Saturn and Dreamcast.

I love my Saturn and have over a hundred titles for it. It does not have the RPG library like the PS1, but Ive stopped playing JRPGs over the past few years.

[Menegrothx]

Every time I go to get some retro games and I look over the PS1 section I usually don't buy anything; either making me me say "meh" or I'd rather have it on another system.

Seriously...?
None of these games are on Saturn/N64/Dreamcast

Crash Team Racing (best kart racer ever)
Silent Hill
Crash Bandicoot 1-3
Jumping Flash! 1&2
Final Fantasy 7-9
Klonoa
Metal Gear Solid
Chrono Cross
Mega Man Legends 2
MediEvil 1&2
GTA
Tenchu 1&2
Tekken 1-3
Final Fantasy Tactics
Driver
Gran Turismo 1&2
Ape Escape
Vagrant Story
Castlevania: Symphony of the Night (in US/EU)
Heart of Darkness
Abe's Odyssee and Exoddus
Spyro the Dragon 1-3
Xenogears
Twisted Metal
http://www.racketboy.com/retro/phenomin ... ps-library

Those are just some examples. A bunch of games that are available on other consoles (Tony Hawk's Pro Skater, Resident Evil, Wipeout etc) became famous on the PS1 first before they got ported to other consoles.

PS1 has one of the most largest and diverse libraries when it comes to excellent games. I dont see how any console gamer could say something like that.

[BoringSupreez]

I'd keep the PS1 first, because of nostalgia and the huge number of great games. If I could have two, I'd add the DC to the list.

[ninjainspandex]

Every time I go to get some retro games and I look over the PS1 section I usually don't buy anything; either making me me say "meh" or I'd rather have it on another system.

Seriously...?
None of these games are on Saturn/N64/Dreamcast

Crash Team Racing (best kart racer ever)
Silent Hill
Crash Bandicoot 1-3
Jumping Flash! 1&2
Final Fantasy 7-9
Klonoa
Metal Gear Solid
Chrono Cross
Mega Man Legends 2
MediEvil 1&2
GTA
Tenchu 1&2
Tekken 1-3
Final Fantasy Tactics
Driver
Gran Turismo 1&2
Ape Escape
Vagrant Story
Castlevania: Symphony of the Night (in US/EU)
Heart of Darkness
Abe's Odyssee and Exoddus
Spyro the Dragon 1-3
Xenogears
Twisted Metal
http://www.racketboy.com/retro/phenomin ... ps-library

Those are just some examples. A bunch of games that are available on other consoles (Tony Hawk's Pro Skater, Resident Evil, Wipeout etc) became famous on the PS1 first before they got ported to other consoles.

PS1 has one of the most largest and diverse libraries when it comes to excellent games. I dont see how any console gamer could say something like that.

hehe they are available on the ps3 on the playstation network

[AppleQueso]

So does giving up a ps1 console and just playing ps1 games on a ps2/ps3 count or not?