
Outkast
Idlewild
2006, LaFace
The sixth (and perhaps final) Outkast album proves that there may well be some merit to burning out rather than fading away. There is something that feels horribly unnatural about writing anything negative about an Outkast album, yet here we are. Not that Idlewild is terrible. There are actually some decent songs throughout. Yet it is mystifyingly mediocre when seen as a follow-up to the brilliant string of records the group had already released. It also feels less like an album than a collection of outtakes, solo tracks and half-written song ideas. Which may well be what it is. Though billed as a companion album to the film of the same name, only seven of the album's 25 tracks are from the movie. That's right, I said 25 tracks. 79 minutes if you're wondering. This is way, way too much. If this was Big Boi and Dre and the height of their game, such an abundance of music would be a good thing. You'd press play with the intention of settling in for a long listening session. Instead, you'll find yourself reaching for the track-skip button constantly by the time the album hits its mid-point. The opener "Mighty 'O'" is actually kind of awesome. It's got a pretty excellent synth beat and finds both rappers going hard and coming off effortlessly. And there are some moments of brilliance throughout - Andre's "Idlewild Blue" is actually a pretty cool 12-bar blues composition, and Big Boi's "N2U" shows him pulling off some straight pop impressively. There's also some nice guest appearances here - Snoop and Weezy on "Hollywood Divorce," Killer Mike on "In Your Dreams," and Janelle Monae on "Call The Law" are all standouts. But there is so much going against this album. There's just no restraint. Why all
the horrible skits about going to see the movie or bootlegging the DVD? Then there's "Makes No Sense At All" and closer, "A Bad Note," two of the most ironic choices of clever song titles. Previous Outkast albums have been praised for being challenging listens. But the difference is those challenges gave way to reward. The only challenge here is making it to the end of the album in one sitting without feeling totally upset that this is likely how Outkast ended their legacy as a duo.




