What a great title to kick off the new year with! I played through most of it in 2014, but finished out the final episode last night. I really enjoyed my time with this game. I love Telltale's ability to bring comic books to life while retaining their comic book aesthetic. I took a ton of screenshots, which you can browse through here if you don't mind lots of visual spoilers.
I like how the game handled choice. I really had a hard time to deciding what to do at the choice points and the ticking timer gave the game a sense of momentum and made you feel like a sheriff who was always improvising and making things up as he went along. I wish there was a bit more of an element of being able to choose the wrong guy in this whodunit mystery, but if there had been, I likely would have botched it all up, because the game as it is already reminded me multiple times along the way that I had forgotten important details of the case.
If you want to see the end game summary of what choices I made, they are behind the spoiler tags. Warning: if you haven't played this before, you will see which characters died based on my decisions.