AppleQueso wrote:I like minimalism sometimes. I really dislike the look of something like, say, Windows 8 though.
Of course i'm of the opinion that everything can work if it's pulled off right.
One of the biggest problems with W8's "metro/modern" UI graphical design (I could rant for hours about its actual usage mechanics) is that it lacks both iconography and consistency. In a traditional graphical OS, you can expect an application's icon to look the same and perform the same each time you launch it, and you expect it to be easy enough to remember what it looks like at a glance.
In Windows 8 (and more so in Windows Phone), most apps' live tiles both lack color and a consistent image. Live tiles - by nature - will always be displaying changing images and information, so you can never truly grasp where everything is on the start screen with just a glance. The only way that the start screen is useful is if you want to passively glance at information across many apps, and don't care about specifics. But, that isn't how most people use their computers, and even if it is, it is too minimal to be really useful, and is better-suited to lockscreen info-feeds like Android's "daydream" feature than anything.
Plus, now that Windows Phone 8.1 encourages all app icons to be transparent to accommodate custom backgrounds, you can be sure that the use of color to memorize an icon will be a thing of the past for the OS to an even greater degree.