prfsnl_gmr wrote:Luke wrote:Shocked: I just watched one of my culinary heroes Jaques Pepin place mushrooms in water. Blasphemy I say. Never, ever clean mushrooms with water (unless they are dehydrated). It takes out all the flavor.
Giving them a very quick rinse to get off the dirt and grit is perfectly acceptable. Gourmet magazine conducted an experiment a few years ago to determine how much moisture mushrooms actually absorb if you wash them. The magazine found that mushroom's absorb no more water than most vegetables (i.e., they absorb about as much as asparagus), and the magazine recommended washing them. Accordingly, I now give mushrooms a quick paper-towel bath before using them. I have noticed a decrease in grit but no change in flavor.
Dry paper towel for me, and that is it.
I'll rinse leeks for hours, but when it comes to shrooms I've never tasted one that was gritty or dirty, just "mushroomy". It's not about absorbing water, it's about the loss of that Earthy flavor that makes a mushroom a mushroom. If that means a bit of dirt, fine by me.