BoneSnapDeez wrote:I voted PSO.
After some thought I decided it was the better choice.
FFXI relies heavily on interactions among players - it's much harder to play alone or in small groups.
PSO also has the offline mode for those to just wish to play amongst themselves - this is what I may end up doing given the unreliability of my internet connection.
I agree with your sentiments.
PSO is pretty awesome, I still play it, mostly on Xbox since it's the most convenient to throw on a Hard Drive. You can even play co-op via split screen.
Gamecube version is also great, and you don't even need to worry about having an existing online (offline) account or anything (Xbox requires an old Xbox Live account saved to the system or a patch to bypass).
But I am also biased, because I (almost) NEVER play games online.
I've always been annoyed at FFXI for not offering a single player experience. It really shouldn't have been a numbered game in the series (FF Online would have been more appropriate, and yet Phantasy Star
Online is the one with the solo option

).
...just another lost soul...