What was the last movie you've seen?

[AppleQueso]

I like how peter jackson had to cut all that content to get the lord of the rings books to fit into three movies, but now he's turning a 32 page hobbit book into three oversized movies.

Speaking of Hobbit, word is the first of the Extended Editions should hit soon.

so it's 3 OVER-oversized movies.

(I'm waiting until all 3 are out before I watch any of them)

[dsheinem]

I like how peter jackson had to cut all that content to get the lord of the rings books to fit into three movies, but now he's turning a 32 page hobbit book into three oversized movies.

No shit. And it is a bad idea, too. I already like The Hobbit less than any of the LotR films, and I am skeptical that they will improve. I could MAYBE see two films. Three long films? Too much.

[Luke]

thought: Luke and Dave should get together and do a podcast or something where they just talk about movies.

This might happen.

[fastbilly1]

I like how peter jackson had to cut all that content to get the lord of the rings books to fit into three movies, but now he's turning a 32 page hobbit book into three oversized movies.

No shit. And it is a bad idea, too. I already like The Hobbit less than any of the LotR films, and I am skeptical that they will improve. I could MAYBE see two films. Three long films? Too much.

I plan on editing the footage down to what Rankin Bass gave everyone as The Hobbit.

[dsheinem]

I like how peter jackson had to cut all that content to get the lord of the rings books to fit into three movies, but now he's turning a 32 page hobbit book into three oversized movies.

Speaking of Hobbit, word is the first of the Extended Editions should hit soon.

so it's 3 OVER-oversized movies.

(I'm waiting until all 3 are out before I watch any of them)

Bah, I didn't know there were EEs for these coming, too. Why? He's already adding stuff to the films, does he add more stuff here? Maybe unnecessarily work in a few more LotR films cameos?

Of course, I will still watch them.

(which answers my own "why?" above)

[AppleQueso]

thought: Luke and Dave should get together and do a podcast or something where they just talk about movies.

This might happen.

You two are easily the most knowledgeable film buffs on the board I think, and you also happen to disagree pretty often.

I think it'd make for some neat discussion.

[mjmjr25]

I don't know how we can solve the HP - GoT debate, but I bet this would be helpful.

[noiseredux]

Was hoping the Hustler talk would transition the convo to the HP pr0n parody. No?

[dsheinem]

Was hoping the Hustler talk would transition the convo to the HP pr0n parody. No?

I'd watch 8 of those.

[noiseredux]

I'd watch 7 of them and skip the one with Dobby.