Transitioning from one sister to the other: Ever been done?

[jfrost]

Just felt that this would be a great thread.

I just went out with a girl, but I'm not really feeling it. Not that she isn't nice. She's cute, just a little too shy. I guess I would be into that if I were a hentai manga character.

Her sister, though, seems awesome. She's talkative, I'm more into her styles and tastes, she's pretty...

So, yeah. I was just thinking about this. Is it possible to switch from dating one sister to the other?

Has it ever been done in the history of mankind?

If so, is it innevitably cumbersome? And is it possible to do it without permanently or longlastingly hurting their family?

[ninjainspandex]

Nope never been done once in the history of mankind, if you accomplish this feat you will go down in history next to Abraham Lincoln and Neil Armstrong.

[jfrost]

Arguably with the greatest accomplishment among them.

[Hateshinai]

Can't be done.

[johnny turbo]

OK your chances are very slim. Probably about as likely has having a threesome with them.

[Mehunglo]

Dude you just went out with her. You're not a couple. Do you know if the sister would even go out with you? If the sisters are somewhat close it won't happen. I know I wouldn't date a girl my brother dated.

[Ivo]

I'm not an expert at all, but here is my take on the situation.

I have the impression that this would only be possible (directly transitioning from one to the other) in very specific circumstances, the most likely of which is that the 2nd sister would be someone arguably not as nice as you might have though. And it could also say something about how nice you are, I guess.

It must have happened many times in the history of mankind though.
Sometimes sisters have weird sibling rivalries as well and in such cases I wouldn't even be too surprised to know about cases where there was actually cheating involved (but fortunately I don't know about any). There is even the "cliche" in fiction about cheating occurring with the "best friend" which is probably mostly for extra dramatic effect, but crap like that happens in real life.

Regardless of all that, if you only just went out with the 1st girl (and not more than that), things don't look too bad. Don't go out with her again and break it off as soon as possible. It is the only decent thing to do if you are not really feeling it.

Perhaps you can stay friends, and after many months you can evaluate the situation again and consider asking the other sister out (ideally, the 1st sister will be dating someone by then).

Ivo.

[saturnfan]

It has happened. Unfortunately, I can't really give you any advice since I have no idea how it occurred.

A childhood friend of mine, somewhere around the time we were drifting apart starting dating the younger sister of a mutual friend (I think we were 16, so the younger sister was 14 I think). Not long after that, we basically stopped communicating but apparently he broke up with the girl and starting dating our mutual friend. Than at some point, he went back to the younger sister! This was all over the course of several years, so these relationships were semi-serious.

How this all occurred I'll never know.

[ZeroAX]

I have a friend who slept with 2 brothers (actually dated one of them afterwards) and just kissed the 3rd one. Do you want me to ask her for tips?

[Luke]

So you actually would want to date a girl that doesn't care about her own Sister's feelings? That's is incredibly strange.