Transaction Feedback - Totals - Updated July 4, 2020

Post Your Goods (and possibly trade wishlists) here
User avatar
wip3outguy7
Next-Gen
Posts: 2805
Joined: Tue Jan 13, 2009 12:03 am
Location: Austin

Re: Transaction Feedback - Totals - Updated 2013-01-20

Post by wip3outguy7 »

+1 dedalusdedalus

Fast payment. A pleasure doing business.
User avatar
Mack702
32-bit
Posts: 263
Joined: Thu Mar 01, 2012 7:33 pm
Location: Bakersfield , California

Re: Transaction Feedback - Totals - Updated 2013-01-20

Post by Mack702 »

I hate to say this but this feedback section is starting to remind me of EBAY.

You have all these sellers leaving feedback for buyers after the buyer receives the items and leaves feedback for you. *That's not right*

You people as sellers should leave feedback for buyers as soon as you receive payment.

Not trying to thread crap or anything but I am seeing this more and more on forums and it's completely wrong and opposite of how feedback should be left.

Example..

Buyer pays seller , seller leaves feedback. Buyer receives item , buyer leaves feedback.
dsheinem
Next-Gen
Posts: 23184
Joined: Wed Dec 12, 2007 12:56 pm
Contact:

Re: Transaction Feedback - Totals - Updated 2013-01-20

Post by dsheinem »

Mack702 wrote:I hate to say this but this feedback section is starting to remind me of EBAY.

You have all these sellers leaving feedback for buyers after the buyer receives the items and leaves feedback for you. *That's not right*

You people as sellers should leave feedback for buyers as soon as you receive payment.

Not trying to thread crap or anything but I am seeing this more and more on forums and it's completely wrong and opposite of how feedback should be left.

Example..

Buyer pays seller , seller leaves feedback. Buyer receives item , buyer leaves feedback.
Sometimes post-payment complications can mean the buyer doesn't deserve a +1, even if they paid promptly. For example, they could harass the shit out of you about something shipping and be unreasonable about any delay, file a false claim about not getting something despite confirmation they did, they could take something you sold them at a low price with an understanding of how they'd use it and then try to flip it immediately for profit, etc. These are rare, of course, but I don't subscribe to an auto +1.

Also, there's no rule feedback must be left or must be left immediately. Many of us do feedback posts when a round of deals finishes up...
User avatar
Mack702
32-bit
Posts: 263
Joined: Thu Mar 01, 2012 7:33 pm
Location: Bakersfield , California

Re: Transaction Feedback - Totals - Updated 2013-01-20

Post by Mack702 »

dsheinem wrote:
Mack702 wrote:I hate to say this but this feedback section is starting to remind me of EBAY.

You have all these sellers leaving feedback for buyers after the buyer receives the items and leaves feedback for you. *That's not right*

You people as sellers should leave feedback for buyers as soon as you receive payment.

Not trying to thread crap or anything but I am seeing this more and more on forums and it's completely wrong and opposite of how feedback should be left.

Example..

Buyer pays seller , seller leaves feedback. Buyer receives item , buyer leaves feedback.
Sometimes post-payment complications can mean the buyer doesn't deserve a +1, even if they paid promptly. For example, they could harass the shit out of you about something shipping and be unreasonable about any delay, file a false claim about not getting something despite confirmation they did, they could take something you sold them at a low price with an understanding of how they'd use it and then try to flip it immediately for profit, etc. These are rare, of course, but I don't subscribe to an auto +1.

Also, there's no rule feedback must be left or must be left immediately. Many of us do feedback posts when a round of deals finishes up...
Really man look at the last few pages , after every buyer receives his or her items the sellers leaves feedback.

In all and all that's complete garbage , leave feedback where feedback is due plain and simple.
mjmjr25

Re: Transaction Feedback - Totals - Updated 2013-01-20

Post by mjmjr25 »

Sending money is not a be-all-end-all +1, not in the least. A transaction is complete when it's complete.
User avatar
Mack702
32-bit
Posts: 263
Joined: Thu Mar 01, 2012 7:33 pm
Location: Bakersfield , California

Re: Transaction Feedback - Totals - Updated 2013-01-20

Post by Mack702 »

mjmjr25 wrote:Sending money is not a be-all-end-all +1, not in the least. A transaction is complete when it's complete.
You sellers are afriad of a minus 1 so you wait I understand.
mjmjr25

Re: Transaction Feedback - Totals - Updated 2013-01-20

Post by mjmjr25 »

Mack702 wrote:
mjmjr25 wrote:Sending money is not a be-all-end-all +1, not in the least. A transaction is complete when it's complete.
You sellers are afriad of a minus 1 so you wait I understand.
Yes, can hardly sleep at night.

Maybe you haven't sold enough to know that on occasion buyers can leave you with a negative experience. Try to scam and use that positive feedback against you even.
dsheinem
Next-Gen
Posts: 23184
Joined: Wed Dec 12, 2007 12:56 pm
Contact:

Re: Transaction Feedback - Totals - Updated 2013-01-20

Post by dsheinem »

Mack702 wrote:
In all and all that's complete garbage , leave feedback where feedback is due plain and simple.
Don't be so assumptive. If and when you have a buyer act like a complete dick someday, you'll feel different.
Mack702 wrote:
You sellers are afriad of a minus 1 so you wait I understand.
I think that has little to nothing to do with it, to be honest. And hey, if you don't like the policy you can always try to get members to vote on/push for a change or find a place to trade that has rules you prefer. You could also make it a known condition of any purchases you make here.
User avatar
Mack702
32-bit
Posts: 263
Joined: Thu Mar 01, 2012 7:33 pm
Location: Bakersfield , California

Re: Transaction Feedback - Totals - Updated 2013-01-20

Post by Mack702 »

Just leaving my two cents on things and how I feel about it. Obviously this site is a one way street.
mjmjr25

Re: Transaction Feedback - Totals - Updated 2013-01-20

Post by mjmjr25 »

I had a new member on NA try and tell me he didn't get his game last week (tracking shows the package as delivered).

He then opened a case against me through paypal which was immediatly closed by paypal and he got a warning from the mods on that site.

Noiseredux can verify the pm exchanges, as needed. It was straight up scam...granted, a scam by a moron. Let me go leave him some positive feedback :roll:
Post Reply