Sometimes, I derive pleasure from the simple act of playing a game. Defender, OutRun 2, Mirror's Edge, Soulcalibur 2. These are the games I come back to. They have some kind of "game feel" that makes me feel directly connected to the game mechanics.
Playing Defender feels so physical! Running into an alien rocks me. It's like getting hit by a left hook I never saw coming. I'm better at boxing than I am at Defender

What gives you that "game feel?: Is it something you seek out?