I don't care how good someone is in the ring if they aren't entertaining. There are tons and tons and tons of guys on the indie scene who can put on great matches but are as interesting as mud. That's fine for something like Ring of Honor, or a TNA X-Division, but not on the big stage that is the WWE. Guys like Morrison or Shelton Benjamin just weren't good enough for the WWE. I honestly don't find Evan Bourne entertaining on his own, which is why they always had to have him around someone else to keep people interested. While Morrison had some crazy in ring stunts he could pull of, he just wasn't interesting (remember Mr Ziggles

) and couldn't get his balls out of Melina's purse. There is no excuse for boring guys like that when guys like Punk, Jericho or Ziggler can be these awesome characters on the mic AND put on great matches. Even Daniel Bryan has been pretty entertaining with his current heel character. Those guys deserve the top spots.
However, it's true that a truly brilliant creative mind can make even boring guys entertaining. Unfortunately, the WWE doesn't have any Paul Heymans and probably wouldn't appreciate them if they did because they had the original and got rid of him. Heyman could get ANYONE over. Creative could learn so much from that guy
As for Clay, I appreciate that he's doing something different, but he's not doing it well in my opinion. He doesn't even look comfortable in this role. It looks very forced. I've never been one to give something a thumbs up just because it's different. That's too easy. If you guys enjoy him though, then I guess that's cool. I just think these guys did this gimmick so much better
and seeing big Brotus Clay come out with pretty, dancing girls just makes me miss another guy who was more entertaining than he is right now