Anubis wrote:Personally I find the love for the show to be a bit strange. I understand that the characters are unique, the animation is above average, and altogether it's a fairly competent and well put together show.
That doesn't change the fact that the target demographic is that of young girls. Maybe there is action and humor and etc etc, but the fact remains, most of the people watching this are not who the show is designed for.
My fiance collects MLP, the 80's G1's, or generation 1's, the original MLP's. She collects them for the same reason I play my old, "antiqued" video game systems instead of buying a shiny new XBox 360... it makes her smile, feel happy, and remember fondly her childhood. She also has a great many friends who are into collecting MLP. They all got together last weekend and went to a convention in Rhode Island in which representatives from Hasboro, MLP collectors and fans, and artists involved in the community all got together to dicsuss the series, do trades, etc.
One of the things they talked about was this particular show and the folks from Hasboro never implied that it's target audience is "7 year old girls," but rather, it is targeted towards former MLP childhood fans who are NOW in their 20's and 30's. There's a big market for that kind of stuff, as the current retro game market and the current "boys toys" market shows (anyone checked the price of original transformers on eBay lately??) The new show isn't too bad, and it's a component of the overall community of MLP enthusiasts. They really enjoy it!
I personally am not a fan of MLP, but I see the joy and happiness that it brings her, and it's the same happiness I have when I play a round of Mario Bros 3 or Sonic 2 on my classic consoles. All of a sudden it's 1988 and I'm in my best friends basement facing Mouser! Or it's '91 and I'm plugging in my Genesis for the first time ever and losing track of Sonic because he moves THAT fast.
MLP brings the same feelings and happiness to her. Why should I deny her that, or speak disparigingly about her hobby when my own can, and often is, claimed to be "marketed towards children" and a juvenile waste of time? Understanding how I feel about my own childhood "toys" helps me to understand how she feels, too.
All in all, I feel it's pretty hypocritical to be dissing another group of people's interests/hobby that revolves around toys or cartoons when you yourself spend hours a day surfing video game forums, playing video games, etc. The original market for those, if you recall, was also children... and yet here we all are... two or three decades later, enjoying those kids games over and over again! Nothing wrong with that, and nothing wrong with MLP either. To each his/her own.