Think Geek's iCade

Neo-Geo, Arcade, Portable, & Every Other Platform
Post Reply
dsheinem
Next-Gen
Posts: 23184
Joined: Wed Dec 12, 2007 12:56 pm
Contact:

Think Geek's iCade

Post by dsheinem »

http://www.thinkgeek.com/electronics/retro-gaming/e762/

Image

As a soon-to-be owner of an iPad 2 (thank you work!), I am quite interested in getting one of these. Since they aren't out yet I doubt anyone here has tried one, but I thought I'd ask anyway on the off chance someone has.

Anyone else interested in one?

(Also, if anyone with connections has one they want to send me, I'd be happy to interview the makers of the device for an upcoming podcast episode :mrgreen: )
User avatar
isiolia
Next-Gen
Posts: 5785
Joined: Mon May 16, 2011 1:52 pm
Location: Virginia

Re: Think Geek's iCade

Post by isiolia »

http://kotaku.com/5805374/im-a-little-i ... de-machine may interest you.

I'd agree with some of the comments there though that it's not exactly a cost-effective solution, once you factor in the iPad. Even then, probably kind of situational, since $99 towards input options for other devices with old arcade games available can buy a lot.
dsheinem
Next-Gen
Posts: 23184
Joined: Wed Dec 12, 2007 12:56 pm
Contact:

Re: Think Geek's iCade

Post by dsheinem »

isiolia wrote:http://kotaku.com/5805374/im-a-little-i ... de-machine may interest you.

I'd agree with some of the comments there though that it's not exactly a cost-effective solution, once you factor in the iPad. Even then, probably kind of situational, since $99 towards input options for other devices with old arcade games available can buy a lot.
I'd read that - and since the iPad isn't part of my cost, that doesn't matter to me. Is there a cheaper way to build a better tabletop arcade cabinet?
User avatar
Bradtemple87
Next-Gen
Posts: 4829
Joined: Sun Sep 05, 2010 8:18 pm
Location: Bay Area

Re: Think Geek's iCade

Post by Bradtemple87 »

I remember seeing the unveil video from CES. I think it is a cool idea for the price :)
girlracer
Next-Gen
Posts: 1457
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 3:39 pm
Location: Bedford, IN

Re: Think Geek's iCade

Post by girlracer »

i think they are cool but with the cost of the icade and having to buy ipad, i'd have almost as much in it as i do my mame cocktail table
User avatar
isiolia
Next-Gen
Posts: 5785
Joined: Mon May 16, 2011 1:52 pm
Location: Virginia

Re: Think Geek's iCade

Post by isiolia »

dsheinem wrote:
isiolia wrote:http://kotaku.com/5805374/im-a-little-i ... de-machine may interest you.

I'd agree with some of the comments there though that it's not exactly a cost-effective solution, once you factor in the iPad. Even then, probably kind of situational, since $99 towards input options for other devices with old arcade games available can buy a lot.
I'd read that - and since the iPad isn't part of my cost, that doesn't matter to me. Is there a cheaper way to build a better tabletop arcade cabinet?
Well, that'd depend...

One factor that should really be considered is software support. The iPad is a relatively closed platform - unless jailbroken - and even then is not as robust in terms of support as other platforms. Mame on it doesn't support all games, and has very limited input options outside of the on-screen controller - WiiMote among them for Bluetooth, the iCade? Not as of yet.

The other is the form factor - yes, you net a cute little arcade cabinet, but the functional portion of that amounts to a stand for the iPad (that doesn't charge it, have extra speakers, or anything). It just makes the thing sit upright. In fairness, though the materials may not be that costly, the time it'd take to make it look like that would justify some of the cost.

Still, functionally, it's an input device...which is why I said that.

You can use at least some wired PS3 sticks on a PC, as they're just USB. Or build a stick, or buy one made for the PC, and so on. $99 may not cover every option, but there are a lot of them. Obviously you'll have the most robust software support, configuration, and all that using a PC - and it doesn't take much of one to run most of what Mame offers.

I have an iPad free from work too - I just don't see why I would want to spend $99 just for decent controls on a (relative) handful of games. It'd just be a novelty.
dsheinem
Next-Gen
Posts: 23184
Joined: Wed Dec 12, 2007 12:56 pm
Contact:

Re: Think Geek's iCade

Post by dsheinem »

isiolia wrote: One factor that should really be considered is software support. The iPad is a relatively closed platform - unless jailbroken - and even then is not as robust in terms of support as other platforms. Mame on it doesn't support all games, and has very limited input options outside of the on-screen controller - WiiMote among them for Bluetooth, the iCade? Not as of yet.
There's a promise of more games to come, and there are about 100 Atari titles that are already compatible for only $15.
The other is the form factor - yes, you net a cute little arcade cabinet, but the functional portion of that amounts to a stand for the iPad (that doesn't charge it, have extra speakers, or anything). It just makes the thing sit upright. In fairness, though the materials may not be that costly, the time it'd take to make it look like that would justify some of the cost.
Yeah, it doesn't do anything extra, that's for sure. :?
Still, functionally, it's an input device...which is why I said that.

You can use at least some wired PS3 sticks on a PC, as they're just USB. Or build a stick, or buy one made for the PC, and so on. $99 may not cover every option, but there are a lot of them. Obviously you'll have the most robust software support, configuration, and all that using a PC - and it doesn't take much of one to run most of what Mame offers..
I have a few good quality USB sticks sitting around and a computer or two I could potentially hook up - but all of that would be a bit big for an enclosed tabletop setup, and in my experience tweaking MAME on a per game basis is a bit tedious (as is setting up a good front end).
I have an iPad free from work too - I just don't see why I would want to spend $99 just for decent controls on a (relative) handful of games. It'd just be a novelty.
Yeah, I think that part of the "value" will be in whether or not more games support it. For what it's worth, I contacted the folks who make it to ask for a review unit, so maybe I'll get to share some impressions soon.
User avatar
sneth
32-bit
Posts: 255
Joined: Thu Mar 05, 2009 3:55 pm
Location: Saint Louis
Contact:

Re: Think Geek's iCade

Post by sneth »

it
is
for
people
that
already
have
an
IPAD...........
Last edited by sneth on Fri Jun 17, 2011 11:52 am, edited 1 time in total.
"To preserve biological diversity, is an investment in immortality."
elabit
24-bit
Posts: 132
Joined: Mon Aug 30, 2010 9:29 pm
Location: TAMPA!!!

Re: Think Geek's iCade

Post by elabit »

Ill stick with my astro city cab with a computer and mame in it thank you
Post Reply