IBARA for PS2 (Shmup Review)

Show your reviewing skills by collaborating with other forums members to review games of all ages.
User avatar
hashiriya1
Next-Gen
Posts: 3384
Joined: Sat May 30, 2009 11:59 am
Location: San Francisco Bay

IBARA for PS2 (Shmup Review)

Post by hashiriya1 »

Image


Game: Ibara
Developer: Cave
Publisher: Taito
Release Date: February 23rd, 2006
Genre: Shooter
System: Playstation 2
My Score: 9.5/10

Image


It was the summer of 2005 when I walked into the infamous Hirose Entertainment Yard (aka "HEY") arcade in Tokyo's Akihabara to play some shmups. A new one had just arrived from Cave titled 'Ibara' which means "Sculptured Rose". They had 3 of them lined up next to each other so it wasn't long until I could drop my 100 yen in to give it whirl. Upon playing I began to realize something... "This game is a rip-off of Battle Garegga!" From the power-ups to some of the enemies down to your ship's shrapnel destroying enemies, I know I've played this game before. Little did I know at that time was both games, Ibara and Battle Garegga, shared some of the same staff. I was hooked right away. In my mind, this game is Battle Garegga with characters and a plot. I remember dropping about 1500 yen on that game that day (One credit is 100 yen). I would go back there over the months to play it. It was announced in Dengeki Playstation Magazine that Ibara was going to be released for PS2 sometime in 2006.

So February 2006 rolls around and I pick up the game right when the doors opened at a local game shop, well, not my usual shop because my usual shop didn't even stock the game, like a lot of other shops. I plopped down my 7000 yen and took that sucker home. I powered it up and after the fore-credits a deep voice says "IBARA!" followed by a girl yelling "Ah! Kakattekoi!!" Which means "Bring it on!" Yeah, so the taunt worked and I quickly hit the START button. And so began the Arcade Mode. Before the level starts a graphic showing all the boss pilots scrolls up and all of them say in tandem "Watashitachi ga kirei ni shite ageru" which means "We're going to clean you up!" which can be further translated to "We're going to kill you". These girls mean business. But if you know the plot, then their battle cry should be taken literally. They literally want to clean the Earth and make it beautiful. Not so bad, eh?

The game takes place in the 19th century in Nordic Europe in an alternate earth where everything is powered by steam, even aircraft. This technology is called "Edelweiss". You are in control of a retro-futuristic plane and the pilot is named "Bond". You can play simultaneously with another player, the 2P's name is "Dyne". The story is 5 alien women (the bosses of each stage) who look human came to earth and saw how dirty it was. They want to transform earth into a huge rose garden, but they would have to wipe out mankind in order to do so...because you know, man dirtied the place up after all. Bond and Dyne are out to save the earth from the sisters' flamboyant plans. The 5 sisters are lead by a doctor by the name of Teresa Rose (final boss). Teresa Rose's agenda is a bit more sinister than merely transforming earth into a huge rose garden....what could it be??


Image

There are two different modes. Arcade Mode (unlimited continues) and Arrange Mode (no continues). Arcade mode is pretty straightforward. Gather power-ups and destroy the enemies. I prefer "Arrange Mode". Arrange Mode should have just been called "Battle Garegga Mode" because when you choose this mode, the game's controls become like Battle Garegga. Once you obtain the auxiliary side guns, you can toggle them into different firing styles. From 360-degree rotating guns to a homing gun, just choose whatever is right for you. The AI for the homing gun is questionable, but it is still the best mode for me. The Arrange Mode also kicks in a little CAVE flavor. When you hold down the fire button, the stream becomes stronger and the plane becomes slower. In the arcade mode, the stream is at a steady rate, but not as rapid and the plane's speed does not decrease.

Like in Battle Garegga, there is a "rank" bar. For those who have never played Garegga, there is a rank bar that increases every time you collect the bomb power-ups. The higher the rank bar, the more difficult the game becomes. In Garegga and in Ibara's Arcade Mode, the rank bar is invisible. The only way to gauge your rank is to observe enemy bullet patterns and their rate of expulsion. You can keep the game simpler by avoiding such power ups, but they would be needed when fighting more difficult bosses. The best way to beat the game in Arrange Mode is to strategically commit suicide to reset your bar. It does takes practice, but the payoff is satisfying.

Image


The Verdict: 9.5/10

Is this game the perfect shmup? For me it is pretty damn close. It is definitely the best shmup on PS2, IMO. I have absolutely no complaints about this game. Anything that I didn't like in Arcade Mode is remedied in Arrange Mode. This game is challenging, frantic, beautiful, great-sounding...I can go on and on. I've heard complaints about the game being too hard or just a re-skinned dumbed-down Battle Garegga and I understand where they are coming from...but I disagree. This is a whole new game with traits passed down from its lineage. Also...what other shmup has its own line of clothing and cosplay? Heh.

This game is a must-own for all shmup collectors. It can't be had cheap, but it can be had. Get it.

Official Site of the game
http://www.cave.co.jp/gameonline/ibara/index.html


My copy. As always, no pirated or emulated reviews!

Image

Image
User avatar
MrPopo
Moderator
Posts: 24190
Joined: Tue Aug 26, 2008 1:01 pm
Location: Orange County, CA

Re: IBARA for PS2 (Shmup Review)

Post by MrPopo »

I downloaded this a little while ago to try it out (I'm not spending $100 on a game I'm not sure I'll enjoy) and right now I'm going to hold off on it. It's definitely too hard for me. My level of skill is I can consistently get to Stage 3 on Futari and Stage 2 on DaiOuJou. I might pick it up down the road as my skill improves, but right now it's hit or miss as to whether or not I can get to the boss of the first stage.
Also...what other shmup has its own line of clothing and cosplay?
Touhou.
Blizzard Entertainment Software Developer - All comments and views are my own and not representative of the company.
User avatar
t0yrobo
Next-Gen
Posts: 1035
Joined: Wed Aug 13, 2008 1:19 pm
Location: GR MI

Re: IBARA for PS2 (Shmup Review)

Post by t0yrobo »

I've never been able to get into this game, but I've never got into Garrega either so I guess that no surprise. I might be getting it confufed with another game but I think Ibara looked like poo on my tv. I see one of the screenshots you have is from an emulator, do you know if it runs well that way? Now Pink Sweets I played only a few times almost a year ago and I can't wait to get another shot at it, it's weird since I don't normally get into rank heavy games.
dsheinem
Next-Gen
Posts: 23184
Joined: Wed Dec 12, 2007 12:56 pm
Contact:

Re: IBARA for PS2 (Shmup Review)

Post by dsheinem »

Over the past six months or so since I picked it up, Battle Garegga has steadily started to become my favorite shmup. Based on your recommendation and review here, and based on this game's lineage, I had to pick Ibara up (I tried burning a copy but it always froze on me :( ).

Anyway, my copy finally arrived in the mail today and I played the first few levels (I made it to level 3 without continuing). I must say - THANK YOU for highlighting this game. It's like BG on crack. So far I feel that Ibara's arcade mode slightly improves on BG's arcade mode (and it looks prettier!). And though I haven't yet dipped into arrange mode, it sounds very compelling based on the description above. Already I feel that the game is well worth the price of admission (I spent about $90, which isn't too bad), and I may have a hard time deciding between BG and Ibara by the time I've had my fill of both!

Oh, I also have a PS2 copy of DaiOuJou on the way after your recent comparison article finally settled my mind on which version to get. Still, I am curious - you really liked the PS2 port of DDP yet Ibara scores a whole point and a half higher on your scale. What accounts for the extra points for Ibara? What would have made it a "10"?
User avatar
noiseredux
Next-Gen
Posts: 38148
Joined: Fri Nov 14, 2008 1:09 pm
Contact:

Re: IBARA for PS2 (Shmup Review)

Post by noiseredux »

I need this one. Big time.
Image
User avatar
hashiriya1
Next-Gen
Posts: 3384
Joined: Sat May 30, 2009 11:59 am
Location: San Francisco Bay

Re: IBARA for PS2 (Shmup Review)

Post by hashiriya1 »

dsheinem wrote:Over the past six months or so since I picked it up, Battle Garegga has steadily started to become my favorite shmup. Based on your recommendation and review here, and based on this game's lineage, I had to pick Ibara up (I tried burning a copy but it always froze on me :( ).

Anyway, my copy finally arrived in the mail today and I played the first few levels (I made it to level 3 without continuing). I must say - THANK YOU for highlighting this game. It's like BG on crack. So far I feel that Ibara's arcade mode slightly improves on BG's arcade mode (and it looks prettier!). And though I haven't yet dipped into arrange mode, it sounds very compelling based on the description above. Already I feel that the game is well worth the price of admission (I spent about $90, which isn't too bad), and I may have a hard time deciding between BG and Ibara by the time I've had my fill of both!

Oh, I also have a PS2 copy of DaiOuJou on the way after your recent comparison article finally settled my mind on which version to get. Still, I am curious - you really liked the PS2 port of DDP yet Ibara scores a whole point and a half higher on your scale. What accounts for the extra points for Ibara? What would have made it a "10"?

You're welcome.

Reading this review again, I see I could have done a better job. This was when I first started doing reviews and I wasn't sure which direction I should go. I could write an even better, in-depth one if I did it again. I'll save that for Ibara's sequel (Pink Sweets) which will be released on XBOX 360 next month.

I could say Ibara gets extra points just for being a descendant of Battle Garegga. :)

In all seriousness though, Ibara gets extra points for its difficulty level changing in realtime based on your level of power-ups. It keeps you on your toes knowing when and when not to power-up, and when to suicide to adjust the difficulty level on a certain boss or section of a level. It also gets extra kudos for more varied weapon system (Arrange mode). DOJ is the 3rd game in the series, but the weapon system hasn't really evolved much other than the addition of the Hyper. Also, Ibara just feels like a better game that was meticulously thought-out. This is all based purely on my preference and opinion, of course.

I am glad you got a real copy of the game. It's just something every shmup fan should own.
leeperry
Newbie
Posts: 5
Joined: Sat Feb 05, 2011 8:57 pm

Re: IBARA for PS2 (Shmup Review)

Post by leeperry »

yeah, great gameplay but the lowres graphics really look horrid on component/native VGA.
FerretGamer
Next-Gen
Posts: 1366
Joined: Tue Jan 25, 2011 2:10 pm
Location: Now residing in sunny San Diego!

Re: IBARA for PS2 (Shmup Review)

Post by FerretGamer »

I need to start stashing some cash away to purchase this shmup. Along with about several thousands dollars worth of others. :)

Slightly off topic, I did pick up a copy of Homura off ebay thanks to your review. I'm looking forward to getting comfortable with that one.

BTW, I've added your blog to my favorites. It helps me keep track of some worthy imports. :P
Exhuminator wrote:Sega gonna Sega.
User avatar
hashiriya1
Next-Gen
Posts: 3384
Joined: Sat May 30, 2009 11:59 am
Location: San Francisco Bay

Re: IBARA for PS2 (Shmup Review)

Post by hashiriya1 »

FerretGamer wrote:I need to start stashing some cash away to purchase this shmup. Along with about several thousands dollars worth of others. :)

Slightly off topic, I did pick up a copy of Homura off ebay thanks to your review. I'm looking forward to getting comfortable with that one.

BTW, I've added your blog to my favorites. It helps me keep track of some worthy imports. :P

Thanks. You won't regret buying Homura. It's a great shmup!
User avatar
d123456
Next-Gen
Posts: 1268
Joined: Tue Jan 30, 2007 6:39 pm
Location: The Netherlands, Almere
Contact:

Re: IBARA for PS2 (Shmup Review)

Post by d123456 »

After Raiden Fighters, Battle Garegga is still my favorite. I have been dying to play Ibara, but would probably get the pcb, because the ps2 game´s price is ridiculous.
Optimizing PS2 games 480p (progressive) and 240p gsm hdtv
http://www.racketboy.com/forum/viewtopi ... 25&t=30389
Post Reply