Future Article Ideas

Talk about just about anything else that is non-gaming here, but keep it clean
User avatar
crux
128-bit
Posts: 808
Joined: Wed Oct 29, 2008 5:52 pm
Location: Indiana

Re: Future Article Ideas

Post by crux »

Oh, and I'll give a BIG second to nick's idea of more information on the more obscure consoles (though not just consoles HE didn't grow up with :P ). Trying to sort out information about various consoles, and more specifically, the best titles on various underdog consoles can be an arduous task of sorting through contrary opinions and bias. The hidden gems articles on the site have the right idea, but applying them to less successful consoles and filtering out the bias is a more difficult task (and becomes more difficult the less successful the console is).

Better categorizing as a whole could go a long way. Rather than breaking it down as SNES - platforming, we could just have the option of having an advanced search where we could filter games by genre OR platform OR both. Those, like myself, that own a myriad of consoles might want to know what the best platformers OVERALL are. There could even be options for developer and sub-genres or filters for reviews, though let's not get ahead of ourselves.

And while my mind's a tinkering, articles don't NEED to be set in stone. For instance, I've seen various subjective choices in articles that should be objective (such as the "rare & valuable" articles). Thinking back to my controller fetish, it would be VERY difficult to narrow down every unique controller because of the elusiveness and the sheer quantity of controllers that exist. A sort of wiki quality or a robust editing feature would go a long way.
User avatar
Ack
Moderator
Posts: 22583
Joined: Tue Mar 18, 2008 4:26 pm
Location: Atlanta, GA

Re: Future Article Ideas

Post by Ack »

I've been watching this topic pretty closely, and it's given me a few laughs, not because what I think what you guys are asking for is wrong, but because we've recently been considering some of these same ideas.

Just a couple of quick questions. When you guys ask for more obscure consoles, would you also like to see much more in terms of old school? I mean, 1970s consoles, since we haven't given them too much love. Would you like the really weird ones, like the R-Zone, to pop up? Do you guys want to see articles covering knock offs, examining things like the Turbo Duo or FC Twin or some of those Russian consoles so seldom seen in the West?

Also, when you want information about genres, would you enjoy a history, or more like a rough guide on how to approach it? Do you want us to continue to give breakdowns of genres by console, such as my recent article on fighting games for the Nintendo 64, or do you prefer the more open approach of the Hidden Gems articles? Do you want us to publish control schemes and relevant information, such as how much space a game might take up on a memory card?

I'm assuming for peripherals you'd want everything from the PlayStation Dex Drive to the Master System's 3D glasses, arranged by console.

And keep the ideas coming in guys. This site's for everybody, so it only makes sense that we'd be interested in what you guys want to know and think is lacking from the Internet.
Image
superlarz
128-bit
Posts: 770
Joined: Tue Nov 11, 2008 8:01 pm
Location: San Diego
Contact:

Re: Future Article Ideas

Post by superlarz »

As a lot of folks have said already, articles on more obscure systems would be awesome. More Jaguar and 3D0 articles would be great. I like the review section database idea as well. I would love to see more opinions of people on this forum on older games.
owned: Atari VCS, Intellivision, ColecoVision, NES, NES2, Sega Master System, Turbografx-16, Genesis/Sega CD Model 1, Genesis/Sega CD Model 2/32x, SNES, Atari Jaguar, Virtual Boy, GBA, 3DO, Saturn, Playstation, PSone, N64, Dreamcast, PS2, Gamecube, Xbox, PSP, Xbox 360, Wii, PS3
wanted: Cd-I, Neo Geo AES
User avatar
nickfil
Next-Gen
Posts: 1708
Joined: Tue Jun 03, 2008 11:36 am
Location: philadephia

Re: Future Article Ideas

Post by nickfil »

crux wrote:Something that would be right up my alley (and something I'm probably most qualified to actually write) is an article about the myriad of novelty controllers out there. I can assure you that, at least on English speaking sites, such an article or website does not exist. In fact, I've only ever been able to find a VERY small handful of personal lists or queries about novelty controllers on the internet whatsoever. I'm not sure how many people would be interested in such a thing, but I guarantee there's a plethora of controllers that vast majority of people don't know exist.
I'd be really into that.
User avatar
nickfil
Next-Gen
Posts: 1708
Joined: Tue Jun 03, 2008 11:36 am
Location: philadephia

Re: Future Article Ideas

Post by nickfil »

nickfil wrote:Maybe even fold the defining games and hidden gems articles together? That way a user could click 'snes' and get a breakdown like "platformers- defining" and "platformers- hidden gems" And then maybe add links to the other snes articles at the end of that article for easy jumping around the site.
I just wanted to repeat that although i do endorse having more content on more obscure systems, i think folding defining and hidden is also good idea because in essence defining and hidden gems they are the same idea. If you want to know what the good games are: there they are. Why separate them? I know when i first found the site those were the two kinds of articles i clicked on the most, and was a little frustrated that they wern't listed in the same place. Though, it seems like they might have been at one time? With the 'obvious choices' set up in the hidden gems section.

I think that this kind of stacking articles together per system is a good idea in general. The set up that racketboy has is a good one to spread out fewer content, but i think the site has grown enough (IMHO) to start to condense the information in a straightforward logical way and not have it feel empty. Plus- i think that the casual first time user who just pops in "good snes games" into google after getting one at a flea market or something will enjoy having all the information for the entirety of the system in one link rather than buried in 5 links.

and just a thought- maybe a talk back forum link at the bottom of every article would be good. Get people in the community.

but yeah.... article ideas.... uh.... maybe retrospectives? A whole artical on a franchise of games or something like that. Games in chronological order. What made them stand out compared to their brothers. Maybe a rank best to worst or something like that. I know it would help me out on more obscure or convoluted franchises like king of fighters/fatal fury, thief, turok, monkey island, or alone in the dark.
superlarz
128-bit
Posts: 770
Joined: Tue Nov 11, 2008 8:01 pm
Location: San Diego
Contact:

Re: Future Article Ideas

Post by superlarz »

nickfil wrote:
nickfil wrote:Maybe even fold the defining games and hidden gems articles together? That way a user could click 'snes' and get a breakdown like "platformers- defining" and "platformers- hidden gems" And then maybe add links to the other snes articles at the end of that article for easy jumping around the site.
I just wanted to repeat that although i do endorse having more content on more obscure systems, i think folding defining and hidden is also good idea because in essence defining and hidden gems they are the same idea. If you want to know what the good games are: there they are. Why separate them? I know when i first found the site those were the two kinds of articles i clicked on the most, and was a little frustrated that they wern't listed in the same place. Though, it seems like they might have been at one time? With the 'obvious choices' set up in the hidden gems section.

I think that this kind of stacking articles together per system is a good idea in general. The set up that racketboy has is a good one to spread out fewer content, but i think the site has grown enough (IMHO) to start to condense the information in a straightforward logical way and not have it feel empty. Plus- i think that the casual first time user who just pops in "good snes games" into google after getting one at a flea market or something will enjoy having all the information for the entirety of the system in one link rather than buried in 5 links.

and just a thought- maybe a talk back forum link at the bottom of every article would be good. Get people in the community.

but yeah.... article ideas.... uh.... maybe retrospectives? A whole artical on a franchise of games or something like that. Games in chronological order. What made them stand out compared to their brothers. Maybe a rank best to worst or something like that. I know it would help me out on more obscure or convoluted franchises like king of fighters/fatal fury, thief, turok, monkey island, or alone in the dark.

I like having them separate. I feel like defining games are a lot more "casual" and the hidden gems are more "hardcore." Maybe they can more easily be linked together.
owned: Atari VCS, Intellivision, ColecoVision, NES, NES2, Sega Master System, Turbografx-16, Genesis/Sega CD Model 1, Genesis/Sega CD Model 2/32x, SNES, Atari Jaguar, Virtual Boy, GBA, 3DO, Saturn, Playstation, PSone, N64, Dreamcast, PS2, Gamecube, Xbox, PSP, Xbox 360, Wii, PS3
wanted: Cd-I, Neo Geo AES
User avatar
crux
128-bit
Posts: 808
Joined: Wed Oct 29, 2008 5:52 pm
Location: Indiana

Re: Future Article Ideas

Post by crux »

Ack wrote:Just a couple of quick questions. When you guys ask for more obscure consoles, would you also like to see much more in terms of old school? I mean, 1970s consoles, since we haven't given them too much love. Would you like the really weird ones, like the R-Zone, to pop up? Do you guys want to see articles covering knock offs, examining things like the Turbo Duo or FC Twin or some of those Russian consoles so seldom seen in the West?

Also, when you want information about genres, would you enjoy a history, or more like a rough guide on how to approach it? Do you want us to continue to give breakdowns of genres by console, such as my recent article on fighting games for the Nintendo 64, or do you prefer the more open approach of the Hidden Gems articles? Do you want us to publish control schemes and relevant information, such as how much space a game might take up on a memory card?

I'm assuming for peripherals you'd want everything from the PlayStation Dex Drive to the Master System's 3D glasses, arranged by console.
I doubt I only speak for myself when I say that I'm interested in any systems with good games. If 1970s consoles fit the bill, then I don't see why not. Even consoles without good games could be covered in an article though, especially as there are quite a few collectors who visit this site. Spin-off consoles even have a place, especially when compared and contrasted to the consoles they're spun-off from.

I would prefer at least an option for an open approach to genres, since I have every single console listed in topics save for the 32x (which I'll get around to eventually). I also prefer more of a rough guide rather than a more encyclopedic effort, as I'm not as interested in the history of, say, all platformers as I am interested in the best platformers ever made.

Similarly, the posts need to be cleaned up a lot in topics. If I click on Dreamcast under topics I won't see the Undiscovered Dreamcast Games article until page six. Sure, I can find it more easily under hidden gems, but what if I didn't know I was looking for it? A better system for organization would go a really long way, though I do understand it would involve changing the format around quite a bit. I don't think the nitty gritty like memory card space is important, but certainly more detail wouldn't hurt, so long as it strays from the convoluted.

As for peripherals, my own interests are pretty specific: Controllers that have a use. The world of hardware is an even larger one and would be VERY difficult to tie down. But I could definitely see how articles about hardware like Dex Drive could be useful, and SegaScope (the 3D glasses) seems pretty damn cool. :)

As for the controllers, some time in the next few days I'll take some pictures of my controller collection and see how much interest it garners. I don't collect things that serve use only as a collector's item (though a few come very close), like the Resident Evil chainsaw controller or Yuna's Tiny Bee Gun controller, I don't try to collect multiple of various types of controllers (I only have two arcade sticks, for instance, and I'm missing light guns for a system or two), and I don't collect inferior controllers (no R.O.B. or Power Glove, sorry), but I guarantee I have a few controllers that 99% of people have never seen before. And I do KNOW of most the controllers that only serve as a collector's item. :) My knowledge fades a ton when it comes to stuff like Famicom controllers and older peripherals (see: http://www.ne.jp/asahi/oroti/famicom/cont00.htm). If I knew Japanese my hunt for novelty controllers would be a lot more productive. I only knew about a few of those Famicom controllers before I found that site. I'm sure there must be lots of controllers I'm completely oblivious about for older systems.
User avatar
Ack
Moderator
Posts: 22583
Joined: Tue Mar 18, 2008 4:26 pm
Location: Atlanta, GA

Re: Future Article Ideas

Post by Ack »

Please tell me you have the PS1 Beatmania Turntable. I so want one of those.

I also don't necessarily mean the history of every game, but covering major additions, such as how the change to 3D has affected a genre, or where and how a particular genre mechanic came into existence.

I'm liking how this topic is going. Come on guys, keep giving us your thoughts!
Image
User avatar
miked
128-bit
Posts: 693
Joined: Sat Jun 14, 2008 9:28 pm

Re: Future Article Ideas

Post by miked »

More on the emulation side of things, I always thought a nice article would be making an all in one retro machine with the softmods of the last generation consoles. PS2, Xbox and GameCube. The Wii is pretty amazing and coming up all the time in this area, but I think its too new and is on a whole other price level.

Obviously the softmodded Xbox wins this situation, but what if you don't have an Xbox? All three could be compared with pros and cons in price, emulation quality, and additional features(like the Xbox's great multimedia capabilities). The Gamecube is the cheaper of the three but has a terrible controller for emulators and the SD Media Launcher is somewhat pricey. I feel the GBA player and better overall Gamecube game library somewhat makes up for this though, plus many GC compatible controller adapters are now available thanks to the Wii.

I have almost no knowledge of the PS2 softmod but I hear its emulation quality is kinda bad......which is terrible since it probably has the most retro friendly controller.(feel free to correct me if im wrong on this.....)

Excuse me while I take a breathe...........

As you can see this would take TONS of research and also might be considered piracy in some eyes, but for the space concerned gamer like myself(No game room, and I have a wife and kid), it would be very useful helping one decide which all in one retro machine best fits they're needs.
User avatar
corn619
Next-Gen
Posts: 2270
Joined: Sat Mar 08, 2008 3:48 pm
Location: Lincoln, Rhode Island

Re: Future Article Ideas

Post by corn619 »

nickfil wrote:
glynnahab wrote:A game database, if you will. With user-submitted reviews the way its done now, a reviews sections that was nicely organized could really become quite thorough in the end - especially with a community of this size. And, in order to filter out the crap reviews by those of us who lack the communication skills to properly write a good review, a voting system could be implemented so that people could know which reviews were of quality. (1-5 star rating of the review itself, or something similar...)
I like this idea. Maybe have it be a seperate box on the homepage. Newest forum posts next to newest game reviews.
MrPopo wrote:If you have an idea for an article, do the research, and submit it to Racket, I'm sure he wouldn't turn it away. If you took the time and the effort to figure out something a bit esoteric then there's probably other people who'd be interested in it. Or hell, people who didn't even know about it would find out about the awesomeness.
also- racket is all over his own forum. Chances are if you write something that deserves it, he'll ask you if he can post it. Thats how my neo geo thing ended up on the front page.

Although- I'm not sure if the original post was just to suggest ideas for articles and then have someone else do the grunt work. If so then all i have is the rolly eye guy for that. :roll:
I'm liking the database idea as well. Then you could all see the articles, reviews and postings etc just by clicking on the game title. Maybe even info from other sites.
Post Reply