My opinion of every Sonic game released.

[Anayo]

Sonic 3 definitely describes the perfect sonic experience. Add in Sonic & Knuckles locked on and it gets even better.

I agree. It's the ultimate Sonic experience if you ask me.

[fast]

If Sonic Adventure could have the entire game play like the first stage, it would have been awesome. Sadly third stage on is fairly poor.

I need to play the SMS/GG sonics again, its been years.

[MrPopo]

You know how Sega could completely redeem the franchise?

Sonic 3 & Knuckles HD.

[dsheinem]

The Sonic games have gotten progressively worse from Sonic 1 --> most recent Sonic games. Seriously, every entry has been a little poorer than the last - to the point where the series is now horrendous. That means:

1. Sonic the Hedgehog - 1991 - BEST
2. Sonic 2 - 1992 - WORSE
3. Sonic CD - 1993 - WORSENING MORE
4. Sonic 3 - 1994 - WORSENING STILL
5. Sonic & Knuckles - 1994 - WORSER
6. Sonic 3D - 1997 - MORE WORSER
7. Sonic Adventure - 1998 - WORSERER
8. Sonic Adventure 2 - 2001 - EVEN WORSERER
9. Sonic Heroes - 2003 - MORE WORSERER THAN EVEN THOSE
10. Shadow the Hedgehog - 2005 - STILL WORSERER YET
11. Sonic the Hedgehog - 2006 - WORSERERER
12. Sonic and the Secret Rings - 2007 - WORSTEST
13. Sonic Unleashed - 2008 - WORSTESEST
14.? Sonic and the Black Knight - 2009 - BY FAR THE WORST SONIC EVER?

The spin-offs (Spinball, Sonic Riders, etc.) have been of more irregular quality - meaning they haven't necessarily gotten worse as time progressed.

As for the portable games, they are all over the place - I think the GBA games are better than the Game Gear games, but the PSP games are kinda poor...

In any case, Sega just needs to put out something like this: http://www.racketboy.com/retro/sega/200 ... in-hd.html in which Sonic is alone (no friends), does not talk, and is completely, entirely in 2D. Make it a $10-20 download and then all could be forgiven.

[RyaNtheSlayA]

The Sonic games have gotten progressively worse from Sonic 1 --> most recent Sonic games. Seriously, every entry has been a little poorer than the last - to the point where the series is now horrendous. That means:

1. Sonic the Hedgehog - 1991 - BEST
2. Sonic 2 - 1992 - WORSE
3. Sonic CD - 1993 - WORSENING MORE
4. Sonic 3 - 1994 - WORSENING STILL
5. Sonic & Knuckles - 1994 - WORSER
6. Sonic 3D - 1997 - MORE WORSER
7. Sonic Adventure - 1998 - WORSERER
8. Sonic Adventure 2 - 2001 - EVEN WORSERER
9. Sonic Heroes - 2003 - MORE WORSERER THAN EVEN THOSE
10. Shadow the Hedgehog - 2005 - STILL WORSERER YET
11. Sonic the Hedgehog - 2006 - WORSERERER
12. Sonic and the Secret Rings - 2007 - WORSTEST
13. Sonic Unleashed - 2008 - WORSTESEST
14.? Sonic and the Black Knight - 2009 - BY FAR THE WORST SONIC EVER?

The spin-offs (Spinball, Sonic Riders, etc.) have been of more irregular quality - meaning they haven't necessarily gotten worse as time progressed.

As for the portable games, they are all over the place - I think the GBA games are better than the Game Gear games, but the PSP games are kinda poor...

In any case, Sega just needs to put out something like this: http://www.racketboy.com/retro/sega/200 ... in-hd.html in which Sonic is alone (no friends), does not talk, and is completely, entirely in 2D. Make it a $10-20 download and then all could be forgiven.

This has to be the most broken post I have seen in a long time. Everybody has opinions but learn what words are. I mean "worserer"? What the hell.

[Hatta]

Man, what's with all the Sonic 2 hate? I've always considered it to be far and away the best in the series. I wasn't aware that this was a controversial opinion, though I know some prefer Sonic CD.

[dsheinem]

This has to be the most broken post I have seen in a long time. Everybody has opinions but learn what words are. I mean "worserer"? What the hell.

Don't even try to pretend you can school me on grammar, kiddo. I'll take your ass to the shed and back again.

[Mozgus]

This has to be the most broken post I have seen in a long time. Everybody has opinions but learn what words are. I mean "worserer"? What the hell.

The irony must burn like a thousand suns.

[The Apprentice]

This has to be the most broken post I have seen in a long time. Everybody has opinions but learn what words are. I mean "worserer"? What the hell.

Games overall: B/C (Import seen great, USA side is meh,

[Zork]

Man, what's with all the Sonic 2 hate? I've always considered it to be far and away the best in the series. I wasn't aware that this was a controversial opinion, though I know some prefer Sonic CD.

I know right? I figured that everyone's favorite Sonic game pretty much went like this, they either liked Sonic 2, Sonic 3 & Knuckles, or Sonic CD.

I don't really understand whats wrong with Sonic 2, and I especially don't understand how it's easy. I actually thought this game was way harder than Sonic 3 & Knuckles. I breezed through that game as a kid and still do now. Sonic 2 always gave me problems after you got to Oil Ocean.