Two more reviews, but they’re both bad, unfortunately.
Netflix’s
The Midnight Club is a bad show, well made. It’s based on a Christopher Pike book about teenagers in hospice care who meet, at midnight, to tell ghost stories, and the series is a love letter to Christopher Pike novels more generally (i.e., the thin, cheesy, young adult horror novels from the late eighties and early nineties with gaudy, neon covers). The hospice is located in an old home, which may be haunted and was definitely a cult HQ at one point; so, there are plenty of spooky mysteries throughout the season. Moreover, the teenagers stories are all short adaptation of various Christopher Pike novels; so, there are lots of shorter, spooky tales within the broader plot.
Unfortunately, and like Christopher Pike novels, none of the shorter stories are particularly scary or engaging, meaning the show doesn’t work well as a horror anthology. Moreover, the central mysteries aren’t that scary or compelling either, and the main character is pretty unlikeable. (Also, she makes a lot of bone-headed decisions for someone who’s supposed to be really smart.) The supporting characters are better and they’re all pretty well-developed for a show with such a large cast. Nothing much really happens to them, though, other than that they occasionally struggle with their terminal conditions or diseases. Accordingly, the show is pretty much just about teenagers dying from cancer, which is scary is a real life sort of way, but not great for a horror series.
Finally, and perhaps most damningly, I could never determine who might be the target audience for this show. While the ghost stories might be compelling for eight-year-olds, the show isn’t even remotely scary. Nonetheless, its language and content are frequently wildly inappropriate for anyone except older teens. I can see why the show failed to resonate with anyone and while I am frequently frustrated by Netflix’s decisions to cancel shows - we really, really needed one more season of GLOW! - I think they made a wise decision to pull the plug on The Midnight Club.
Before I Wake is another Mike Flanagan horror film, and while I really like list of his work, it stinks. It’s about a family mourning the loss of their son who foster a kid with the ability to materialize his dreams. (Put another way, what he dreams becomes reality while he’s asleep.) This is fine when he’s having pleasant dreams, but his nightmares might kill you. (The movie doesn’t address this, but I suspect his teenage years will be very, very awkward…) The movie is not scary at all, and the kid who’s supposed to be eight to ten sounds more like a four-year old. The other characters mostly act like idiots and make unexplainable decisions, but not in a fun “Why are you going to the basement alone?!” sort of way. The acting’s sort of flat, and the ending is kind of tasteless. Not recommended at all.
prfsnl_gmr’s Series of TERROR!
1. Marianne (Netflix) -
2. Midnight Mass (Netflix) -

3. The Midnight Club -
prfsnl_gmr’s Movies of MADNESS!
1. Cottage Country -
2. Kumari (Netflix) -

3. Grave Encounters (Kanopy) -

4. The Vourdelak (Kanopy) -

5. Before I Wake -
