Re: Sony Trinitron WEGA RLOD Twenty Dollar Repair Guide
Posted: Wed Jan 18, 2012 9:45 pm
the FS100 is a waste of money. That is the most basic of the Wegas. You can get it much cheaper if you look. A good resource for features is Wikipedia.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FD_Trinitron/WEGA
Basically the FS series is the basic line. It has a 3 line digital comb filter, basic speakers, 1 s-video port
The FV is the highest end SD version with a 3D comb filter, better speakers, Picture in Picture, and 2 s-video ports.
The HS is the basic version or HD TVs. Only available in Hi-Scan
The XS is the next up and these are Super Fine Pitch
Finally the XBR is the top of the line, Found in Super Fine Pitch and Hi-Scan. XBR is supposed to have better blacks.
Now if the model number ends in 3 numbers, ie. KV-36FVxxx it has auto 16:9 enhancement. If it has only two i.e. KV-36FVxx it has manual 16:9 enhancement. 16:9 enhance is when the TV compresses the 480 scan lines to the middle of the screen so that the TV is displaying the full 480 lines of any Widescreen material, instead of the black bars consuming some of that resolution. The auto detect means that it can automatically detect incoming anamorphic WS material, manual it cannot. The auto/manual matters little for video games. You can still turn in on manually with auto sets. But its good that it has 16:9 enhancement, because it will allow you to play the few retro WS games in the proper ratio. NiGHTS and DK64 have WS options.
The other major difference between Wegas are KD vs KV. Some Wegas model start with KD. The KD ones have ATSC digital tuners, meaning they will be able to pick up the new digital signals that TV stations are broadcasting with now. With non KD wegas you will need a digital antenna and a digital converter box if you wish to watch TV via antenna.
In my opinion, of those TVs, you should get the KV-36FV15. The FV will be much better than the FS series. The FS are very common. The FVs are not. If you really wanted an FS, I believe you could get it much cheaper.
I feel there is no good reason to get a HD set for pre Dreamcast retro gaming, and plenty of reason not too. However, if you really wanted an HDTV Wega, wait out for a Super Fine Pitch TV to come up on Craigslist. The HD version you noted is Hi-Scan. For about the same price you could wait and get a Super Fine Pitch (more vertical resolution), a better series: the XBR, and the digital ATSC tuner. Wait out a model like KD-34XBR960 (best Sony HD CRT made).
My ultimate opinion for a Sony Wega for retro gaming is the KV-xxFV310 or KV-xxFV300. The 310 is the best SD TV Sony made. It comes in 27in, 32in, and 36in. The 310 is slightly better than the 300 because it has two component ports, and a newer bezel. The 300 is also a fine TV, get whichever one you find first, unless you really need two component inputs. IMO, the HD Wegas add nothing to retro gaming, and only detract in that they break light gun compatibility and the upscale the signal to HD. Up scaling is never better than watching in the original resolution.
If you are set on getting an HD Wega, and you plan on ever watching HD content, it would be foolish to get a model without DVI/HDCP or HDMI. Component, although capable of 720p/1080i HD does not have HDCP. HDCP is a copy protection protocol, whereby if the TV is not HDCP compliant, the player, be it a up scaling DVD player, Blu-Ray player, HD-DVD Player, or HD cable/satellite box will refuse to play video material with HDCP on it. A lot of HD stuff has HDCP. If you are connected component it will refuse, and only output SD, or output nothing at all. So it would be very wise to wait for an HD CRT with preferably HDMI (ALL HDMI is HDCP compliant, no exceptions) or DVI/HDCP (DVI can be either HDCP compliant or not, but I believe all Wegas with DVI ports are HDCP compliant). Component output can never be HDCP complaint. HDMI would be better because thats the standard for HD signals now, and is much more common. This is a big deal
Note 36in. and 32in TVs are heavy, and large. You will need two strong men, possibly 3 to lift them, so plan ahead when you go to buy one.
Its is truly sad that CRT tech is gone. It many ways it is superior to all other current TVs technologies. It was capable of true multisync, meaning it could display all resolutions at the original resolution, without upscaling, although this was never implemented on consumer TVs. All HD CRTs available to the consumer upscale the signal to a single resolution, usually 1080i.
Edited: Added in HDCP section
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FD_Trinitron/WEGA
Basically the FS series is the basic line. It has a 3 line digital comb filter, basic speakers, 1 s-video port
The FV is the highest end SD version with a 3D comb filter, better speakers, Picture in Picture, and 2 s-video ports.
The HS is the basic version or HD TVs. Only available in Hi-Scan
The XS is the next up and these are Super Fine Pitch
Finally the XBR is the top of the line, Found in Super Fine Pitch and Hi-Scan. XBR is supposed to have better blacks.
Now if the model number ends in 3 numbers, ie. KV-36FVxxx it has auto 16:9 enhancement. If it has only two i.e. KV-36FVxx it has manual 16:9 enhancement. 16:9 enhance is when the TV compresses the 480 scan lines to the middle of the screen so that the TV is displaying the full 480 lines of any Widescreen material, instead of the black bars consuming some of that resolution. The auto detect means that it can automatically detect incoming anamorphic WS material, manual it cannot. The auto/manual matters little for video games. You can still turn in on manually with auto sets. But its good that it has 16:9 enhancement, because it will allow you to play the few retro WS games in the proper ratio. NiGHTS and DK64 have WS options.
The other major difference between Wegas are KD vs KV. Some Wegas model start with KD. The KD ones have ATSC digital tuners, meaning they will be able to pick up the new digital signals that TV stations are broadcasting with now. With non KD wegas you will need a digital antenna and a digital converter box if you wish to watch TV via antenna.
In my opinion, of those TVs, you should get the KV-36FV15. The FV will be much better than the FS series. The FS are very common. The FVs are not. If you really wanted an FS, I believe you could get it much cheaper.
I feel there is no good reason to get a HD set for pre Dreamcast retro gaming, and plenty of reason not too. However, if you really wanted an HDTV Wega, wait out for a Super Fine Pitch TV to come up on Craigslist. The HD version you noted is Hi-Scan. For about the same price you could wait and get a Super Fine Pitch (more vertical resolution), a better series: the XBR, and the digital ATSC tuner. Wait out a model like KD-34XBR960 (best Sony HD CRT made).
My ultimate opinion for a Sony Wega for retro gaming is the KV-xxFV310 or KV-xxFV300. The 310 is the best SD TV Sony made. It comes in 27in, 32in, and 36in. The 310 is slightly better than the 300 because it has two component ports, and a newer bezel. The 300 is also a fine TV, get whichever one you find first, unless you really need two component inputs. IMO, the HD Wegas add nothing to retro gaming, and only detract in that they break light gun compatibility and the upscale the signal to HD. Up scaling is never better than watching in the original resolution.
If you are set on getting an HD Wega, and you plan on ever watching HD content, it would be foolish to get a model without DVI/HDCP or HDMI. Component, although capable of 720p/1080i HD does not have HDCP. HDCP is a copy protection protocol, whereby if the TV is not HDCP compliant, the player, be it a up scaling DVD player, Blu-Ray player, HD-DVD Player, or HD cable/satellite box will refuse to play video material with HDCP on it. A lot of HD stuff has HDCP. If you are connected component it will refuse, and only output SD, or output nothing at all. So it would be very wise to wait for an HD CRT with preferably HDMI (ALL HDMI is HDCP compliant, no exceptions) or DVI/HDCP (DVI can be either HDCP compliant or not, but I believe all Wegas with DVI ports are HDCP compliant). Component output can never be HDCP complaint. HDMI would be better because thats the standard for HD signals now, and is much more common. This is a big deal
Note 36in. and 32in TVs are heavy, and large. You will need two strong men, possibly 3 to lift them, so plan ahead when you go to buy one.
Its is truly sad that CRT tech is gone. It many ways it is superior to all other current TVs technologies. It was capable of true multisync, meaning it could display all resolutions at the original resolution, without upscaling, although this was never implemented on consumer TVs. All HD CRTs available to the consumer upscale the signal to a single resolution, usually 1080i.
Edited: Added in HDCP section