dsheinem wrote:ejamer wrote:
Frankly, the only notable design improvement I see for PSP2 is a second analog stick... Color me not impressed.
So the inclusion of a physical media option, a touch pad, an OLED touch screen, gyroscope, and 3G built in aren't significant design improvements over the PSPGo?
Not really.
Physical media isn't a surprise after the disaster that was PSP Go, and replacing UMDs with a better option is also an obvious move. Do you really think this counts as a notable improvement? Sorry, I don't.
Is a touch pad/screen going to improve my gaming experience on this system? Maybe... but given Sony's focus on core gaming experiences I'm not confident about that. I guess it doesn't hurt to include it, as long as developers don't feel the need to make it a silly gimmick and instead only use the feature where appropriate. I can't shake the feeling that this is just a "me too" addition though, copying Nintendo and Apple and hoping to leech off their casual gaming success even though nothing else about this system is designed with casual gaming in mind.
Even on home consoles, the appeal of motion controls is quite limited. When you need to move and rotate your entire screen on a portable system to control a game it seems even more limited. There will be few games that make good use of it... but I'm betting right now you'll be able to count the really good ones on one hand. The gyroscope is more interesting for gaming than the GPS though, so I guess it's got that going for it.
As for the 3G option, I don't see that as a meaningful improvement. Online gaming isn't that important
to me, especially for short, pick-up-and-play sessions on a portable system. The expectation that a contract will be needed only makes that feature less appealing.
So you've basically got a more powerful PSP with a few gimmicks throw in. Let me repeat: color me not impressed.
dsheinem wrote:
Sony has done very well world-wide with both the PS3 and PSP. They've proven that they don't need to be #1 in the market as there is enough market share for two portables to be successful. If things go as well with the PSP2 as they did with the PSP, they should be fine.
Very true. The PSP is a success, just not as big a success as some of the competitors.
I expected that Sony would rethink things and push to expand their market share instead of just accepting the status quo with PSP 2. I was wrong. This is a very safe and predictable upgrade that actually discards any progress made with the physical design of PSP Go in favor of returning to the older and more familiar original PSP system.
It is what it is, but I admit that I was hoping for something more.