ok here is the problem everyone wants games that hold up today but compared to what??
just accept the games for what they are you arent going to have ps3 graphics and gameplay on a ps1 game also you gotta remember 3d games were relatively new then sso control schemes for the games were sometimes bad i cant even remember if any game on the ps1 used both dual analog sticks for player control.
ok here is what i like to play and you might agree "still hold up today"
alien trilogy (great fps) it is not the same as on atari jaguar but it is really fun!!!
dave mirra freestyle bmx (not the remix) imo it is the best dave mirra game
c the contra adventure and also contra legacy of war (clow can use 3d glasses!!)
now these games were hated by contra fans but i have just recently beat these 2 games and they were both worth the time and effort.
soulblade how could this not hold up?? great game great game playand highly underated in the series
ace combat 2 & 3 are great airplane games from namco
twisted metal series is great too alot of fun to be had with those games
mega man and mega man x games are really good good games for the ps
r type delta is a great shmup
g. darius while not as good as on the saturn is still great if you dont have it for the saturn (or ps2)
raystorm and ray crisis are also great shmups for the system costly for ps games but worth it
mass destruction is a great game too (also on the saturn)
marvel super heroes vs street fighter i mean does it not hold up??
resident evil series cant go wrong there
here is a sleeper rogue trip 2012 made by the same people who made twisted metal
and if you have a light gun get all the light gun games for the retro arcade shooter in you!!!
i tried to stay away from rpg's because everyone says they are the best games (which is a overstated opinion) and i feel that home consoles were meant to bring home the arcade to your living room and i never played final fantasy in the arcade
and thats my opinion !