I've been thinking about this more and more and I've thought of something else. I too love nuanced villainy, because I love any characters that are real enough to be understood. I also love using my imagination to fill in the gaps of weak writing to come to an understanding of characters that the scripts gave little thought to. So on the one hand there's well-written nuance, and on the other there's shallow writing that gets nuanced out of necessity by imagination.pierrot wrote:All right, I can kinda dig it. I prefer more nuanced villainy, but put that way, I can kind of see the draw.
The thing with Kefka is that I don't feel like his one-noteness is a result of the writers not being thorough or not having a clear vision as to what his motivations are. He's a purposeful sociopath, and because of that, I'm not compelled to apply headcanon to fix a perceived story deficit. What we wind up with is the kind of character disturbs and fascinates me most: the one that can't be reasoned with or understood. He's like his own eldritch horror. He's Q. He's a person with no humanity, who feels nothing strongly nor takes anything seriously, and isn't tormented about it. Not even a little bit. So you can't even get the catharsis of his regret or hesitation or sadness anything. There's no closure to be had because he's never going to have an introspective moment that will allow it. All you can do is fret about the unpredictable scope of what he's capable of. So I loved that -- a character conceived as purely destructive who doesn't even value the destruction he visits upon others.
But I do get your perspective for sure. I think my favorite antagonist of all time is Magneto -- at least as he's presented in the movies. You see him getting separated from his parents on his way to a concentration camp and you get it. You understand the validity of his worldview.
On Metroid Fusion: Okaaaay. This game is creeps as hale. Like I'm actively creeped. For the first time in playing a Metroid game I don't feel alone, and it is not the good kind of not alone. It is the oppressive and over-your-shoulder kind. Actually, it's a bit like Return of Samus in that regard. But UGH. I watched the SA-X patrol by with a flashlight in an adjacent corridor just now and I was like NOPE!!
This is going to be fun.

