Xeogred wrote:I'd like to see this discussion keep going... what's more or less of a Mario game?
Yoshi's Island vs Super Mario Bros 2
I guess I'd vote SMB2, since you can at least play as Mario. It does feel closer to the Mario formula, but that may more be due to how unique Yoshi was at the time.
Bionic Commando is one hell of a game. I think its similar to Umihara, not only in that its a grappling hook game, but that it has a bit of a learning curve before it really becomes enjoyable.I think I'd personally place Gimmick above it, but both are insanely good games that mix tight design with a ton of freedom of expression.
NSMBU was the only one of the new games that really knocked me back. I enjoyed the others (2 the least by a good margin), but U was really damn good. I still need to play the Luigi game.