It wasn't just shovelware games, just any game under a certain price ($10 IIRC). Which means, yeah, it could be a sports or shovelware game (not that this makes it OK) but it could also be a AAA game. For example I got a disc only copy of Metal Gear Solid 2 in GameStop's disc-only bin, and quite a few others. Normally I don't purchase disc only games, but I felt like I was rescuing them!RCBH928 wrote:If they are throwing manuals and covers for shovelware games thats understandable but I think games like The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess would still fetch more money CIB than in a nylon wrapper.
No, but GameStop doesn't think so. Trade-in value and sale price was always a flat price no matter what was included or not. Collectors care, but again, most gamers probably don't. If a collector walks into a GameStop for a certain game and the only copy is disc-only (they would put it in a generic case) they wouldn't buy it, but the average gamer might buy it.RCBH928 wrote:Unless there is some sort of a culture clash where Americans value disc only just as much as CIB.
GameStop will open up new games so they can put the case on the shelf for display purposes (and keep the disc behind the counter so no one could steal the game) but when they run out of sealed copies they sell this opened copy as NEW and for the same price. So the factory wrap was removed. The case was on the shelf, who knows how many people handled it. And the disc was handled at LEAST twice, once to take it out and once to put it back. And you're telling me that I should pay the same price as a sealed copy? If they took $5 off for this that would make all the difference in my opinion. But I think it's outrageous to sell anything that's "open box" for the same price as factory sealed. But I guess most people don't care and bought copies like that, and that just tells GameStop that it's OK to do it.

