List: Best 30 Gamecube Games (What do you want on yr shelf)

[Sarge]

I feel P.N. 03 is the one that feels the most out of place on the list, but that's just me.

It only feels out of place because it's not #1.

Ha! Well, we could always drop Dark Legacy. I mean, a top 30 without Paper Mario is a sad, sad list.

[dsheinem]

Why is RE4 here when it is also on the Wii list? Wasn't the argument there that it was on the Wii b/c it was a superior platform? Isn't that the same argument against some of the HM games (e.g. Wind Waker, Hulk, etc.)?

[Reprise]

What about Killer7? It's one of my favourite games of that generation, due to its unique style and gameplay. Upon searching on Google, people are claiming the PS2 version suffers from some graphical problems and longer load times.

[dsheinem]

What about Killer7? It's one of my favourite games of that generation, due to its unique style and gameplay. Upon searching on Google, people are claiming the PS2 version suffers from some graphical problems and longer load times.

Yeah, the GCN is the best version. I'd put it on here over PN 03 by a mile. Certainly over RE4 or Gauntlet.

[Exhuminator]

I say drop Super Mario Strikers and Gauntlet, add The Thousand Year Door and Killer 7.

Leave PN.03 alone you heathens!

[mjmjr25]

RE4 GCN and RE4 Wii are really completely different experiences because of the play style. I enjoy both and will keep both - it sounds like many would keep both in their top 30's...but, if i've misinterpreted that, i'll drop it out.

Gauntlet will be out based on the above comments.

Mario Strikers received high praise and was considered better by some (not all) superior to the Wii version.

Adding Paper Mario and Killer 7 to honorable mention.

[retrosportsgamer]

Dudes.

Again: Ribbit King. Show some love homies.

Massive love for Ribbit King - I am a frolfer at heart. I love zany golf games, so golf when your club is a hammer and catapult and your ball is a golf, well that is just groovy.

Ribbit King is on PS2 also :buzzkill:

[fastbilly1]

Dudes.

Again: Ribbit King. Show some love homies.

Massive love for Ribbit King - I am a frolfer at heart. I love zany golf games, so golf when your club is a hammer and catapult and your ball is a golf, well that is just groovy.

Ribbit King is on PS2 also :buzzkill:

Cube version is superior in load times. Other than that they are the same game.

[Forlorn Drifter]

Wow, hadn't realized the Cubivore price jumped so much. It was like $10 when I got it, and $30 when I checked a year ago.

I finally have a rare game!

[Reprise]

RE4 GCN and RE4 Wii are really completely different experiences because of the play style.

I thought your could play the Wii edition of RE4 with the Gamecube controller (or, at the least, with the classic controller), thus making it the best of both worlds?