Re: Zig's SNES Repros
Posted: Wed Oct 21, 2009 10:35 pm
Hey Ziggy, I found out about your project just today and I gotta say what you've done is truly awesome. I've actually dreamed of doing the same thing for Earthbound 3 on the GBA but while I'm still wishing you're actually doing. I've also thought about basically replacing abused cover art on official game cartridges with high-quality official looking prints as I can't stand a good game having a scuffed and/or scratched up cover. The perfectionist in me can't stand it, but I just can't seem to find the time and my printer being a cheap piece of junk doesn't help to motivate me.
But anyway enough of that, about your draft... while I agree that measures need to be taken to ensure your carts aren't mistaken for official copies, making the cartridge practically scream "I'M A PIRATE JOB!" does take some of the glitter away from the project. Specifically, I feel like changing the "Super Nintendo Entertainment System" seems a bit much. The game is for the Super Nintendo right?
The "SNS-ZIG-USA" text is a great idea and the watermark idea is definitely a must. I think it would be even better if the watermark was fashioned in the style of a stamp, it would be very Nintendo-ish somehow and would look more attractive than simply having text.
Along with that, how about modifying the Official Seal of Quality to show that it's not quite official? Like maybe have it say "Un-Official NINTENDO Project Cartridge"?
I hope you don't mind but I kinda messed around with your original draft to give you a visual idea of what I mean:

I also added "By Ziggy587" to ensure no one has any doubt that this is not an official cover or cartridge, as well as kinda put a signature on the work you've done. In the event that someone else out there does something similar it would be cool to let others know which custom covers were done by you and which ones were not. Just an idea anyway.
But anyway enough of that, about your draft... while I agree that measures need to be taken to ensure your carts aren't mistaken for official copies, making the cartridge practically scream "I'M A PIRATE JOB!" does take some of the glitter away from the project. Specifically, I feel like changing the "Super Nintendo Entertainment System" seems a bit much. The game is for the Super Nintendo right?
The "SNS-ZIG-USA" text is a great idea and the watermark idea is definitely a must. I think it would be even better if the watermark was fashioned in the style of a stamp, it would be very Nintendo-ish somehow and would look more attractive than simply having text.
Along with that, how about modifying the Official Seal of Quality to show that it's not quite official? Like maybe have it say "Un-Official NINTENDO Project Cartridge"?
I hope you don't mind but I kinda messed around with your original draft to give you a visual idea of what I mean:

I also added "By Ziggy587" to ensure no one has any doubt that this is not an official cover or cartridge, as well as kinda put a signature on the work you've done. In the event that someone else out there does something similar it would be cool to let others know which custom covers were done by you and which ones were not. Just an idea anyway.