DMC4 is the one that's unfairly slogged, too this day I guess. I seriously feel like I'm one of the only fans and I have no idea why. I know the competition isn't steep with Japanese action games being thinner this gen, so not to discredit it either, but it's probably my favorite action game this gen next to Metal Gear Rising or something. But DMC4 is even deeper. Nero was different enough from Dante to change things up a bit, cool bosses that were done well even when they were huge in scale, and yeah. The game is amazing, beat it on every difficulty, beat Blood Palace, etc, I got obsessed with it. Maybe up in the air against the others for fans, but to consider it lower than B grade or something definitely makes my head spin. Combat doesn't get much more intricate and if we think of other sequels... man it blows Ninja Gaiden 2 (Xbox/360) away for me, and NG3 sounded like it completely sucked (DMC2 level? lol). And I wouldn't even hesitate to put it above God of War, etc.
... also to just put it out on the table, I know there's a crap ton of backtracking throughout the entire game practically, but let's not kid ourselves. That's definitely in DMC1 and DMC3 as well and pretty much Japanese game design in general, definitely Capcom's stuff for sure. People with those complaints must loathe Metroidvania's and such? lol.
Granted it was the first DMC I completely beat and playing the heck out of so there might be some nostalgia/bias... buuuuuuut nah, it's badass and I can't wait to replay it after I put the HD collection to rest.
Gameplay wise definitely more consistent with the series itself than RE4 was to RE (but hey I love RE4, haha).
On that note I thought about it today, but I still really hope they reboot RE. I actually want that to happen and might be disgusted if they don't, on the other hand I still don't have any interest in DmC. It didn't take me long to figure out the difference here... DMC had very strong personality/character, Dante was very if not even moreso established as a character/persona than anyone in the RE series, and yeah. RE on the other hand I love the death, but beyond liking Jill a bit and the Leon/Ada fever, it's never been anything I've thought much about when it comes to characters. Wesker was good, but then RE5 happened. And cue more reasons I want a reboot since they've kind of just ruined a lot of stuff and with all the characters and gameplay style changes and new viruses and and and it's just way too damn cluttered and convoluted beyond repair at this point.