Page 2 of 3
Re: Game of the Year 2008
Posted: Sun Jan 18, 2009 9:21 pm
by Chrono
I voted GTA 4
I'll go flagellate myself now
Re: Game of the Year 2008
Posted: Sun Jan 18, 2009 9:21 pm
by Citizin
AwesomeMonstar wrote:Oh yeah... l4d kicks ass.
Left 4 Dead was shallow and boring. I'd say the poll's fine how it is now with the "other" option. You don't have many X360 exclusives up there but that's what it gets for being too much like a pc(as far as games go that is).
Re: Game of the Year 2008
Posted: Sun Jan 18, 2009 9:46 pm
by AwesomeMonstar
Citizin wrote:AwesomeMonstar wrote:Oh yeah... l4d kicks ass.
Left 4 Dead was shallow and boring. I'd say the poll's fine how it is now with the "other" option. You don't have many X360 exclusives up there but that's what it gets for being too much like a pc(as far as games go that is).
You're right, the game's so shallow and so boring that been getting awards left and right. Anyways, your blatant fanboyism reminded me of fable 2. Peter Molyneux sophomore attempt nailed down the vision he tried so hard to get in the first. It's also pretty swell co-op game, and is well supported already through dlc. A good, pretty, fun lengthy adventure. Classy game indeed.
Re: Game of the Year 2008
Posted: Sun Jan 18, 2009 11:53 pm
by Peffico
Ehh I find brawl to be the most complete game on the list. So thats my vote really.
Re: Game of the Year 2008
Posted: Mon Jan 19, 2009 12:49 am
by RyaNtheSlayA
Citizin wrote:AwesomeMonstar wrote:Oh yeah... l4d kicks ass.
Left 4 Dead was shallow and boring. I'd say the poll's fine how it is now with the "other" option. You don't have many X360 exclusives up there but that's what it gets for being too much like a pc(as far as games go that is).
thank the mod's for the other option.
Re: Game of the Year 2008
Posted: Mon Jan 19, 2009 12:54 am
by Citizin
AwesomeMonstar wrote:Citizin wrote:AwesomeMonstar wrote:Oh yeah... l4d kicks ass.
Left 4 Dead was shallow and boring. I'd say the poll's fine how it is now with the "other" option. You don't have many X360 exclusives up there but that's what it gets for being too much like a pc(as far as games go that is).
You're right, the game's so shallow and so boring that been getting awards left and right. Anyways, your blatant fanboyism reminded me of fable 2. Peter Molyneux sophomore attempt nailed down the vision he tried so hard to get in the first. It's also pretty swell co-op game, and is well supported already through dlc. A good, pretty, fun lengthy adventure. Classy game indeed.
You seem to fit the fanboy description a lot more than me by thinking it's such a great game based on all the awards it got, and since I think different, I am completely wrong

Re: Game of the Year 2008
Posted: Mon Jan 19, 2009 1:39 am
by The Apprentice
My vote goes out to Braid.
Re: Game of the Year 2008
Posted: Mon Jan 19, 2009 2:11 pm
by Kevman
Super Smash Bros. Brawl
Re: Game of the Year 2008
Posted: Mon Jan 19, 2009 3:53 pm
by Krooze L-Roy
Fallout and GTA I enjoyed, but not enough to finish them. Same goes for Braid. I definitely got a kick out of Mirror's Edge and L4D, with ME probably my favorite "full" game this year, but I think I got more fun out of my downloads than anything. MM9 and Galaga Legions were brilliant, and the one I found myself playing and enjoying the most was N+.
Re: Game of the Year 2008
Posted: Mon Jan 19, 2009 4:42 pm
by fastbilly1
I would say Left4Dead, but Ive not enough experience with it yet. So Subterranean Animism,