racketboy.com

final fight cd wrote:

emwearz wrote:3D it could work very well

...or 3D could work like shit. i can only think of one game that has benefited from going 2D to 3D: mario 64. mario 64 kicks so much ass, and everybody knows this.

The Zelda franchise would like a word with you.

Only briefly played the original, but I keep envisioning a new one being something like Maximo for ps2.

I'd like to see them do something similar to what they did with New Super Mario Bros Wii.

Kid Icarus is a game about jumping and shooting short range arrows. I think it would suck as a first person shooter, it might work as a 3D action game if they found a good way to do lock on targeting for the shooting (maybe take notes from a game like Gungrave).

And ultimately, it has to lead to you flying, and the flying level should feel really liberating.

I don't know, 2.5D seems like the best way to go in my opinion. And I agree with keeping it hard as hell.

final fight cd wrote:

emwearz wrote:3D it could work very well

...or 3D could work like shit. i can only think of one game that has benefited from going 2D to 3D: mario 64. mario 64 kicks so much ass, and everybody knows this.

the rest has just been shit jobs. i can only think of a few off the top of my head, but they include: sonic, castlevania, earthworm jim, contra, mortal kombat, donkey kong 64. the list can go on and on.

true or false: games transitioning from 2D to 3D is pure shit? true; this is based on fact, not opinion.

I would love a kid icurus in a zelda twilight princess form would be epic

and have you played zelda twilight princess? or ocarina? or windwaker? they were great examples of taking a 2D game and making it 3D ! Sure 2D is good but even sonic had a shining moment in 3D on the dreamcast? I personally hated mario 64 ive always enjoyed mario in 2D never in 3D. Sonic I perfer in 2D but love playing the dreamcast releases!

For you to rule out games going from 2D to 3D and claim that mario 64 is the be all to end all of 2D to 3D games is just stupid!

Was there some sort of easy mode on Kid Icarus? I ask because I loved the game when it first came out and I beat it, I believe without any hints. I'm not bragging because I'm generally not that good at games and there's no way I could have done that with Metroid. This was one of the reasons I liked the game so much. It was challenging but fair and a mortal could finish it without resorting to the Nintendo Fun Club Hint Line.

so i forgot about the zelda series and metroid prime series. please forgive me.

opinion: i have always thought most games, but NOT ALL, transitioning from 2D to 3D have just been awful, including the sonic adventures.

opinion: i would rather see the game released as a FMV than a 3D game.

fact: racketboy.com is awesome.

Considering Kid Icarus took heavy influence from Metroid for obvious reasons, I think 2D or 2D.5 would probably be the way to go. Metroid was always a better game in 2D. Castlevania is also a great example of 2D entries being superior to the 3D games. Metroid Prime was a great game, btu I could never see Kid Icarus succeeding as a open world FPS. Then again, Nintendo is known for pulling awesomeness out of their ass so who knowns.

Knowing the trend with Kid Icarus games it will most likely use the Metroid engine anyhow.

Use the following password and you will be on the last level with all items and you will get a strange ending.

KidKid Icarus
KidKid Icarus

final fight cd wrote:

emwearz wrote:3D it could work very well

...or 3D could work like shit. i can only think of one game that has benefited from going 2D to 3D: mario 64. mario 64 kicks so much ass, and everybody knows this.

the rest has just been shit jobs. i can only think of a few off the top of my head, but they include: sonic, castlevania, earthworm jim, contra, mortal kombat, donkey kong 64. the list can go on and on.

true or false: games transitioning from 2D to 3D is pure shit? true; this is based on fact, not opinion.

Zelda: Ocarina of Time
Metroid Prime
Final Fantasy series
...and I for one loved Mega Man Legends.
(and hey I liked DK64, I still can't figure out what's supposedly so bad about it. Liked it far more than DKC3 at least.)

3D Kid Icarus could work, but 2D would be preferable. We're sorta passed the age where every 2D franchise revival has to be in 3D, so I could see them keeping this game in the classic vein.

I never played much of the NES Kid Icarus, though oddly enough I owned the Game Boy one and played it off and on. Never did get very far.