dsheinem wrote:I think that, as with something like FF7, the series has become one of those that it is "cool to hate" on because it was so popular and critically heralded. People blow small issues way out of proportion or find things to nitpick as a way of setting themselves aside from the chorus of people who think the game is great.
This was my second play through of Bioshock and I had the same issues the first time through but gave it another shot because it is so lauded (and cheap). So I'd say I gave the game a fair whack.
I don't count disliking a FPS' gunplay mechanics as a small or nitpick-y issue. I'd say they were pretty crucial and, for me, Bioshock's shooting and player feedback is inferior to quite a few of its contemporaries and even to some games that precede it.
I do not hate Bioshock or Infinite, but I also do not think they are games deserving of such high critical praise. They have beautifully crafted and realised worlds quite unlike most FPS games but I think they also have uninteresting shooting mechanics and limited enemy types. For me they also suffer from being unable to marry issues of objectivism/racism/freewill to more ordinary sci-fi plots and themes.
And Final Fantasy 7 is my favourite Final Fantasy.
