jay_red wrote:Edit:
And right after I hit submit, I realized why they do it, because someone will buy it and clean it up themselves I guess.
Yeah, but how many people WONT buy the dirty item? I bet most people wont. Eye appeal is buy appeal. If you had the choice between two copies of Super Mario World, for the same price, one was mint looking while the other was dirty...
prfsnl_gmr wrote:I am curious, however, what the general rule is with regard to testing games. If people responding to this topic would speak to that topic, I would appreciate it.
One example I like to bring up, in regards to this, is a copy of Ultimate Mortal Kombat 3 for Saturn that I bought off eBay. The seller listed it as "tested, works." When I got it in the mail, there's was a nice scratch on the disc. When I tried the game out, it would load and appeared to work fine, but as soon as you try to load a match it would freeze.
So, simply powering on a game and claiming that it works is not good enough. Of course, we don't always have the time to test every inch of a game, but I have a good idea for suspect optical discs. If the disc has a scratch (beyond light scratches) you could try and rip the disc to an image. So a Saturn game, for example, you could just use ImgBurn to rip it to BIN/CUE. If you get errors during the read, you know you have a problem.