noiseredux wrote:I chose PS2. I think the DualShock feels like an extension of the SNES controller. I always liked the GCN controller -- especially the added weight of the WaveBird, but I never thought the shape of the X and Y buttons were great.
I chose PS2 as well, the GCN controller just didn't work for me. Nothing about it felt right.
If I had to choose a controller from that generation though it would be the Xbox controller s. It's so komfy.
If the PS2 controller had the left stick where the Dpad is, and the stick had ridges on top I would love it. On the converse, if the Cube had four normal sized buttons, and the C stick was like the left stick, it would be perfect.
So I went in the middle, took a working and a broken cube controller and created Cube controller with two real joysticks
alienjesus wrote:Now this one is probably a problem with just me, but because both sticks are at the bottom center (seeing as I use the stick more, I really resent this, it makes me have to stretch over the misplaced d-pad awkwardly) they end up being rather close together. I find that I can actually hit my thumbs together if I move the left stick right and the right stick left.
Nope, not just you. I also have similar problems. Also, I pretty much agreed with everything else you said.
Own: Mega Drive, Saturn, Dreamcast, Playstation 1, Playstation 2, Playstation 3, Playstation 4, Playstation 5, PS Vita, Super Nintendo, Nintendo 64, Gamecube, Wii U, Game Boy Advance, DS, 3DS, Switch, Switch 2, Xbox, Xbox 360
I like both controllers but I don't care for the click triggers of the Gamecube. Having to mash a little harder might be an issue for games that need the click detent and requiring a fast reaction response. Voted PS2, the design is comfortable and has been the same for PS1-PS2-PS3.
noiseredux wrote:I chose PS2. I think the DualShock feels like an extension of the SNES controller. I always liked the GCN controller -- especially the added weight of the WaveBird, but I never thought the shape of the X and Y buttons were great.
