Rurouni_Fencer wrote:Doesn't this whole argument just boil down to: Money vs Personal Entertainment?
A 30+ year old sealed Atari game, Smurfs or not, is pretty rare. There are plenty of people out there with dollar signs in their eyes on eBay that would overpay its value just to resell a mint, sealed Atari game for a profit.
But, if you are the type of gamer/collector that likes to read the actual manual, play the actual cart on your actual 2600/7800, and have the actual box art among other Atari games on a shelf in your den, then it is definitely worth it to break the seal and enjoy YOUR game.
That's the nostalgia factor I mentioned in a previous post. I would not open a sealed, rare cartridge game if I found one, but I have plenty of CIB Super Nintendo games from when I was young and it is fun to flip through the instructions or enjoy the authentic experience of putting the cartridge in the console.
What I find interesting though, is how that experience is so different today. Most games have boring instruction manuals, many without color and Ubisoft wants to abolish instruction manuals completely. The fun experience of putting a cartridge in a console is gone too. Given how flimsy CDs and DVDs are, I'm usually just paranoid about scratches, scuffs or dust whenever I take a disc out of its case, particularly when it's something valuable like my copy of Radiant Silvergun
This is why a lot of the newer stuff I get I don't open. It just isn't as fun to open up modern day games anyway as it was with the older stuff and there's easy ways to play stuff for cheap or for free so I just put the stuff on my shelf and leave em sealed as it just looks nice to the collector in me having sealed stuff on a shelf and maybe someday they'll be worth more than I paid for them