by Raging Justice Wed Dec 28, 2022 12:42 pm
So I finished Beast Wars. As I've stated, it's a good show...BUT, it's not a masterpiece as some have claimed. It is not the greatest piece of media to come out of the franchise, as some have claimed, and it is NOT better than G1. The 1986 G1 movie is still better than ANYTHING in Beast Wars. That said, with Transformers it's all generational. Of course, the people who grew up on it will say it's better than G1, but the fact is many of the show's biggest moments RELY on stuff from G1. The show is constantly in G1's shadow.
That said, the show has great characters, some cool stories, and many cool moments, but it has issues too:
The tone is wildly inconsistent. Dramatic and dark at times, and completely wacky and ridiculous at others. There are times in the show where it's literally just taking the piss
On that note, the show literally feels like a Looney Tunes cartoon at times with over the top slapstick comedy and audio cues that have you expecting Bugs Bunny and Elmer Fudd to pop up on your screen at some point. The comedy in Beast Wars is very off putting at times, it gets far more silly than G1 EVER did.
What does and doesn't cause death is very inconsistent. Characters come back from literally anything in this show (and the over the top comedy plays into that), yet once the writers decide someone needs to die suddenly things become fatal. Also, some of the deaths come out of nowhere and don't really leave an impression. Season 2 very nonchalantly kills off certain characters like it's nothing important, although there is one death that is extremely well done.
There's a rushed romance between two characters that isn't built up well
The character designs vary wildly as characters gain new forms, some of which are REALLY ugly. The new forms just seem like an excuse for new toys, but that's the nature of a Transformers show I guess. Generally speaking, Beast Wars characters are ugly as sin compared to their G1 counterparts, who had nice, clean, designs while Beast Wars designs are kind of a mess. The fact that Beast Wars characters transform into animals makes some of their designs disturbing, like seeing a person's arm be a head with independently moving eyes, or having the head of an animal on ones' chest. Beast Wars toys won't look as good on a shelf as G1 or other Transformers toys...though to be fair nothing in the show is as much of an eyesore as Michael Bay designs.
The whole animal thing is weird too. For some reason, characters in animal mode LITERALLY become those animals, including having to feed on organic beings like mice. Why? They are robots. This makes no sense. In G1, characters like the Dinobots became robotic interpretations of animals but didn't literally need to like feed on animal life like ACTUAL dinosaurs. It's weird, like once characters in Beast Wars transform they stop being robots and become organic beings, even sometimes becoming feral. It's bizarre. I much prefer G1's handling of animal based Transformers, even transformed they were still robots, not organic beings.
Some of the show's cringiest moments revolve around humans, well not technically humans but our prehistoric, simian ancestors since the show takes place on a prehistoric earth. This is a frequent complaint of Transformers fans, the annoying use of human characters. There's a whole episode revolving around this prehistoric girl that had me rolling my eyes. Speaking of the prehistoric thing...
why don't we see more prehistoric creatures pop up on this show like dinosaurs and stuff? The planet seems strangely barren most of the time in terms of wildlife. Like we never see dinosaurs even though some of the characters have dinosaur transformations.
Some of the new characters that show up later in the show are awful. Silver Bolt is literally one of the worst characters I have ever seen in any cartoon ever. In fact, both of the fuzors suck and so does Inferno. Thankfully, Rampage and Depth Charge are both awesome. Silver Bolt really, really drags the show down though and turns one of the coolest characters on the show into a much less cool version of herself by his association with her.
So yeah, lots of issues. I only bring them up because some of the praise Beast Wars gets is off the the charts. It's not up there with TRUE 90s masterpieces like Gargoyles, Batman the Animated Series, or X-Men the Animated series, or other all time greats like Justice League Unlimited, Avatar: the Last Airbender, or Green Lantern: the animated series. It is overall a good show though largely due to cool characters like Tarantula, Rampage, Dino Bot (maybe the show's best character), Depth Charge, Megatron (yeeeesss), Cheetor, Rat Trap (even though he can be annoying), and Black Arachnia (though her character becomes significantly less cool once they start pairing her up with Silver Bolt) and cool G1 based stuff which constitute the show's biggest moments. Honestly, once we get into season 3 it starts to actually feel like an extension of G1. Some individual episodes are extremely good like Code of Hero, Transmutate, and Possession, all must watch episodes. Also, despite my criticism of it, some of the comedy does land in this show. It's a good, B tier show while some of the stuff I mentioned earlier in this paragraph are A tier (heck, Disney's Gargoyles is probably S tier quite honestly...except for season 3). Beast Wars has a lot of excellent moments, but a lot of issues drag it down and its fans overrate the show quite a bit (I've literally seen people call it the best thing in the whole franchise). That said, I am looking forward to the integration of Beast Wars characters into the next live action movie and I will give credit where credit is due, it does seem like Beast Wars re-ignited interest in the Transformers franchise at a time when it was waning. I would say the 1986 movie, Beast Wars, and much as I hate to admit it, the Bay movies have all helped to keep the franchise alive and relevant throughout the years.