Hmm, well if I don't like Obscure, I'll definitely give the sequel a shot too.
Yeah Cold Fear is one of the biggest standouts when I skim through my wishlist. Definitely a high tier choice because of the RE4 comparisons I've always heard. Looks pretty solid.
I've briefly played some of Penumbra back when it was newer but don't remember it pulling me in, but I have my weird PC gaming phases haha. Now that I have a foldout tray and a wireless k/m I do feel a lot more motivated to play PC games lately, which is all I've been doing. So maybe I will give it a shot perhaps in October or something.
One game I will tell you guys I'm glad I did not buy, would be Siren. I couldn't even finish a decent youtube walkthrough of it haha. The gameplay just looked awful. Really disappointing considering I went into it hearing how the original Silent Hill creator and some of that team went off to do that series.
Siren Blood Curse on the PS3 does however look pretty solid. Maybe 2 is decent as well, though I think that was Japan only.