Ok, I've started playing Ziggurat, but this is what else I currently have access to, not including stuff I've wishlisted.
I've broken this list into "retro" and "modern" based on the loose ten-year rule. For all remasters and redux versions, I'm just using the original release date. I've beaten a few of these, but not in their redone version, hence why stuff like BioShock and DOOM 3 are on here:
I've got some options.